A Stowers demand is a settlement offer within the at-fault driver's policy limits that, if the insurer unreasonably refuses it, can make the insurer responsible for a later judgment above those limits. It is one of the strongest tools an injured person has in a Texas claim with limited coverage.
The name comes from a 1929 Texas decision, G.A. Stowers Furniture Co. v. American Indemnity Co., which held that an insurer controlling the defense must act like a prudent person in handling a settlement offer within its policy limits. If it refuses a reasonable offer and a jury later awards more than the policy, the insurer can be liable for the excess.
Texas courts have made the requirements specific. The Texas Supreme Court in American Physicians Insurance Exchange v. Garcia (1994) described three elements: the claim must be within the scope of coverage, the demand must be within the policy limits, and its terms must be such that an ordinarily prudent insurer would accept it, considering the likelihood and size of a potential excess judgment. Courts have also required the offer to release the insured fully.
This matters most when the injuries are serious and the coverage is thin. Texas requires only $30,000 per person in liability coverage under Transportation Code section 601.072. When a claim plainly exceeds the limits, a properly built demand gives the insurer a clear choice: pay the limits now or risk paying more later.
The demand has to be supported. It should include the medical records and bills, proof of lost earnings, the evidence on fault, and enough time to evaluate. A demand that is vague, that adds conditions beyond a release of the insured, or that gives the insurer no real chance to investigate is easy to attack later.
A Stowers demand is also a step toward the full picture of coverage. It often comes after the firm has identified every other policy, including your own uninsured motorist coverage for the gap. Owsley Law Firm prepares these demands for serious injury claims and charges no fee unless it wins.

The doctrine protects the insured driver, not just the injured person. An insurer that gambles with its customer's money by refusing a reasonable offer within limits risks paying the excess itself. That incentive is what gives a well-built demand its force.
A demand that includes extra conditions, such as releases of other parties or confidentiality the insured cannot provide, may not qualify. Clear, unconditional terms and a reasonable time to respond matter.
Stowers demands are most useful early in serious cases with modest limits. Where the at-fault driver has a large commercial policy, the strategy usually turns more on building the full damages case.
How does a Stowers demand work step by step? First, the injured person’s lawyer identifies the at-fault driver’s liability coverage and its limits, and looks for any other policy that might apply. Second, the lawyer assembles the support: medical records and bills, proof of lost earnings, photos, the crash report, and the evidence on fault. Third, the demand is written as an offer to settle for an amount within the limits, in exchange for a full release of the insured, with a stated time to accept. Fourth, the insurer evaluates the offer and either accepts, rejects, or asks for more information. If it rejects and the case later goes to trial with a verdict above the limits, the question becomes whether the rejection was reasonable under the elements the Texas Supreme Court described in American Physicians Insurance Exchange v. Garcia (1994).
What happens when several people are hurt and the limits cannot cover all of them? That situation is common with minimum coverage. In Texas Farmers Insurance Co. v. Soriano (1994), the Texas Supreme Court held that an insurer may enter a reasonable settlement with one of several claimants even if it exhausts or reduces the coverage left for the others. The insurer’s exposure for that settlement depends on whether it had earlier rejected a proper demand within limits from another claimant, and on whether the settlement was reasonable considering the settled claim on its own merits. For injured people, the lesson is that timing matters: when a crash injures several people, a properly supported demand made early can affect how the limited coverage is distributed.
How do insurers respond to these demands? Insurers know the doctrine, and they look for reasons a demand does not qualify. Common objections are that the time to respond was too short for the records provided, that the demand included conditions beyond a release of the insured, such as release of hospital liens the insurer cannot control, or that it did not make clear the offer was within limits. Some insurers respond with requests for more records or a recorded statement, which can be legitimate or can be a way to run the clock. A response asking for information is not a rejection, but a demand that leaves a reasonable time and includes the key records makes those responses harder to justify.
For example, suppose a driver with the Texas minimum of $30,000 per person in liability coverage runs a stop sign and injures another driver, who needs surgery and misses months of work. In this hypothetical, the injured driver’s lawyer sends a demand for the $30,000 limit, with the surgical records, the bills, the wage records, and a 30 day period to accept, offering a full release of the at-fault driver. If the insurer pays, the case against the at-fault driver ends, and the injured driver may still pursue their own underinsured motorist coverage for the rest, subject to that policy’s terms. If the insurer refuses and a later verdict exceeds $30,000, the refusal would be judged under the Garcia elements. The example shows the mechanics only, not what any case would yield.
What edge cases come up? Commercial and rideshare policies with higher limits make Stowers leverage less central, because the claim may fall within the limits anyway. Demands on behalf of minors may need court approval of the settlement, which should be addressed in the demand. When health plans or hospitals have liens, the demand has to account for them without imposing conditions on the insurer that it cannot meet. And when the at-fault driver has more than one policy, such as a personal policy and an employer’s policy, the coverage picture should be confirmed before the demand goes out, because an offer framed around the wrong limits can be challenged.
Mistakes that cost people money
- Sending a demand without the medical records and bills that justify the limits.
- Giving the insurer too little time to evaluate the claim.
- Adding conditions beyond a release of the insured.
Related questions
Does a Stowers demand force the insurer to pay?
No. It gives the insurer a choice. If it unreasonably refuses and a later judgment exceeds the limits, the insurer can be responsible for the excess.
Do I need a lawyer to make one?
The requirements are technical, and a defective demand can be ignored without consequence. Most are prepared by counsel.
What if the driver has more than one policy?
Every policy that covers the driver should be identified before a limits demand is made, so the demand covers the full coverage picture.
How long does an insurer have to respond to a Stowers demand?
No statute sets a fixed period. The demand itself states a deadline, and courts look at whether it gave the insurer a reasonable opportunity to evaluate the claim. Very short deadlines with incomplete records are easier for an insurer to challenge later.
What happens if there are multiple injured people and not enough insurance?
The Texas Supreme Court held in Texas Farmers Insurance Co. v. Soriano (1994) that an insurer may reasonably settle with one claimant even if that reduces or exhausts what is left for others. Early, well-supported demands matter in multi-claimant crashes.
Can a Stowers demand include a hospital lien release?
A demand that requires the insurer to obtain releases it cannot provide, such as releases from third parties, risks being treated as outside the Stowers elements. Liens are usually handled from the settlement proceeds, and the demand should be worded with that in mind.
Does the at-fault driver benefit from a Stowers demand?
Yes. The doctrine protects the insured driver from personal exposure above the policy limits, because an insurer that unreasonably refuses a proper demand within limits can be liable for the excess judgment.
Sources


