Quick answer

A demand letter is the written package that asks the at-fault driver's insurer to pay a specific amount to settle the injury claim. It lays out fault, injuries, treatment, bills, lost income, and the evidence, and it starts the negotiation.

Timing comes first. The demand usually goes out once treatment is finished or the doctors can describe what the future holds, because a claim cannot be valued well while the medical picture is still changing. Sending it too early risks settling before a surgery recommendation or a permanent restriction is known.

A strong demand is built from records, not adjectives. It includes the crash report and photos, witness information or video on fault, the medical records and itemized bills, proof of lost earnings, and a description of how the injury has changed your daily life. Texas counts only medical amounts actually paid or incurred under Civil Practice and Remedies Code section 41.0105, so the bills are presented accordingly.

A written demand can also start the clock on interest. Under Finance Code section 304.104, prejudgment interest in a personal injury case begins to accrue on the earlier of the 180th day after the defendant receives written notice of the claim or the date suit is filed, although it does not apply to future damages.

When the injuries plainly exceed the at-fault driver's coverage, the demand can be structured as a Stowers demand: an offer within the policy limits that, if unreasonably refused, can expose the insurer to a judgment above its limits. That requires careful drafting and enough supporting evidence.

The insurer's first answer is usually lower than the demand. Negotiation follows, and you decide whether to accept any offer. Owsley Law Firm prepares and negotiates demands for clients across Texas, with no fee unless it wins.

What to do, step by step

  1. Finish treatment or get a doctor's statement of future care.
  2. Gather all medical records and itemized bills.
  3. Collect wage proof and photos of the injuries over time.
  4. Send the demand with a clear amount and a reasonable deadline to respond.
Medical records and an MRI film on a light box

Liens and reimbursement claims should be identified before the demand, so the settlement accounts for hospital liens, health plan claims, and Medicare or Medicaid interests.

The demand should match the coverage. If the injuries exceed the at-fault driver's limits, the strategy turns to a policy limits demand and to your own underinsured motorist coverage.

If the insurer does not respond reasonably, the next step is usually a lawsuit filed before the two-year deadline, followed by discovery and often mediation.

What happens step by step after a demand is sent? The adjuster reviews the package, often asks for missing records or a medical authorization, and evaluates the claim internally. The answer usually comes back as a counteroffer, a request for more information, or a denial of fault. From there the sides exchange offers, and each round works best when it is answered with reasons and evidence rather than a new number alone. If talks stall, the options are to keep negotiating, to file suit before the two-year deadline under Civil Practice and Remedies Code section 16.003, or, once a case is pending, to mediate.

What do adjusters look for in the package? Gaps in treatment, a delay between the crash and the first medical visit, inconsistent accounts of how the crash happened, and prior injuries to the same body part are the points they raise most. A demand that deals with those issues up front, with a treating doctor’s explanation or a record that fills the gap, gives the adjuster less room to discount it. Photos of the vehicles, photos of the injuries over time, and a short letter from an employer about missed work give the adjuster something concrete to evaluate.

How do policy limits fit in? The demand should be written with the available coverage in mind. Before a lawsuit, limits are often learned by asking; once a lawsuit is filed, Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 194 requires each party to disclose, without a request, any indemnity and insuring agreements covered by the discovery rules. A demand meant to protect against an insurer’s refusal to settle within limits should track the elements Texas courts apply under the Stowers doctrine: a claim within the scope of coverage, a demand within the policy limits, and terms an ordinarily prudent insurer would accept, considering the likelihood and degree of its exposure to an excess judgment.

What if the demand does not settle the case and suit is filed? Two procedures often shape what comes next. Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 169 sets up an expedited actions process for suits in which the claimants plead that they seek only monetary relief aggregating $325,000 or less, excluding interest, statutory or punitive damages and penalties, and attorney fees and costs, and a party in that process cannot recover a judgment above that amount. Separately, Civil Practice and Remedies Code section 154.021 lets a court refer a pending case to an alternative dispute resolution procedure, and section 154.023 defines mediation as a forum in which an impartial mediator facilitates communication to promote settlement without imposing the mediator’s own judgment on the parties.

For example, suppose a driver is hit at a Houston intersection, treats for a shoulder injury for five months, and is told by the orthopedist that surgery is not needed but some limits may last. The demand would include the crash report, intersection photos, the treatment records and itemized bills, a letter from the employer about missed shifts, and a short account of what changed at home and at work. If the at-fault driver carries only the Texas minimum of 30/60/25 and the claim plainly exceeds $30,000, the demand might be framed within that per-person limit, and the injured driver’s own underinsured motorist claim would be considered next. This illustration is hypothetical and is not a prediction of any result.

A few edge cases come up often. If more than one person was hurt and the at-fault driver has a single per-crash limit, the claims may compete for the same money, so timing and coordination matter. If the insurer denies fault entirely, the demand stage may be short, and the evidence on fault becomes the focus. And benefits from your own policy, such as PIP or MedPay, are claimed from your own insurer separately and do not wait for the demand to the other driver’s insurer.

Mistakes that cost people money

  • Sending a demand before the medical picture is clear.
  • Leaving out bills or records that support the amount.
  • Accepting the first counteroffer without understanding the net after fees, expenses, and liens.

Related questions

More on this topic.

How long does the insurer take to answer a demand?

There is no statutory deadline for the other driver's insurer. Many respond within weeks; a demand usually sets a reasonable response date.

Should I write my own demand?

For a small claim, some people do. For anything involving ongoing care, permanent injury, or limited coverage, counsel usually makes a meaningful difference.

Does the demand amount limit what I can get at trial?

No. A settlement demand does not cap what a jury may award if the case is tried.

What should a car accident demand letter include?

A summary of how the crash happened and why the other driver is at fault, the injuries and treatment, itemized medical bills, proof of lost income, a description of how the injury changed daily life, and a specific amount with a response date. The supporting records should be attached, not just described.

Can I send a demand letter before I finish treatment?

You can, but it is usually a mistake while the medical picture is still changing, because a settlement and release end the claim. The main exception is when the injuries clearly exceed the at-fault driver’s limits; then an earlier policy limits demand may make sense if enough records support it.

What happens if the insurance company ignores my demand letter?

Follow up in writing and keep a record of every contact. If the insurer still does not respond, the usual next step is a lawsuit filed before the two-year deadline. If the demand was a properly made policy limits demand, an unreasonable refusal can matter later under the Stowers doctrine.

Is a demand letter the same as a lawsuit?

No. A demand letter is a settlement request sent to an insurer, and nothing is filed in court. A lawsuit is filed with a court and starts formal discovery, deadlines, and, if the case does not settle, a trial.

Sources

Sources this page relies on

  1. Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 41.0105
  2. Tex. Fin. Code § 304.104
  3. Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 16.003
  4. Texas Rules of Civil Procedure (Supreme Court of Texas)
  5. Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 154.021