Only your facts can answer that. A settlement is good if it fairly covers your medical expenses, lost income, and pain after fees, expenses, and reimbursement claims are paid, given the fault evidence and the insurance that can actually pay. The same number can be excellent for one case and far too low for another.
Start with what the claim is made of. Texas law allows recovery of past and future medical expenses (limited to amounts actually paid or incurred under Civil Practice and Remedies Code section 41.0105), past and future lost earnings, physical pain, mental anguish, physical impairment, and disfigurement. A settlement should be measured against a documented estimate of each, including future care your doctors expect.
Then adjust for fault. Under Chapter 33 of the Civil Practice and Remedies Code, any percentage of fault assigned to you reduces the recovery by that percentage, and 51 percent bars it. An offer on a disputed-fault case is reasonably lower than one where the other driver plainly caused the crash.
Then look at the coverage ceiling. If the at-fault driver carries the Texas minimum of $30,000 per person under Transportation Code section 601.072 and has no other assets, an offer above that policy is not possible from that source alone. Your own underinsured motorist coverage, an employer's commercial policy, or a vehicle owner's policy may add more. A strong case against a small policy is a coverage problem, not a negotiating one.
Finally, compute the net. Subtract the attorney's fee under the written fee agreement, case expenses, and any hospital liens, health plan reimbursement, or Medicare claims. The number you take home is the one to compare against your losses and your future needs.
Never accept an offer before you know your medical future, because a release ends the claim even if you later need surgery. Owsley Law Firm reviews offers for free and charges no fee unless it wins.
What to do, step by step
- Total your medical bills, including amounts actually paid or owed.
- Ask your doctor about future care and put it in writing.
- Add lost income and any lost earning capacity.
- Identify every policy and its limits before responding to an offer.

An early offer reflects what the insurer has seen so far. A detailed demand with records, future care opinions, and wage proof is what moves the number.
When the injury is serious and the coverage is thin, a properly built offer to settle within the policy limits can shift the risk of an excess verdict to the insurer under the Stowers doctrine.
How should you evaluate a specific offer, step by step? First, list your losses in categories: medical expenses paid or owed, expected future care, lost income, and the noneconomic harms of pain, mental anguish, and impairment. Second, attach proof to each category, such as itemized bills, a doctor’s written opinion on future treatment, and wage records. Third, apply a realistic view of fault. Fourth, identify every insurance policy and its limits. Only then compare the offer to the result, after subtracting the fee, case expenses, and any reimbursement claims.
How do insurers arrive at a number? Adjusters review the medical bills and records, the length and type of treatment, the fault evidence, and how a jury in that county might view the case. Gaps in treatment, a delay before the first doctor visit, or a prior injury to the same body part tend to lower an offer. Clear liability evidence, consistent treatment, and objective findings like an MRI tend to raise it. An offer is the insurer’s view of risk, not a measure of what your injuries are worth to you.
What reduces the money you actually keep? Reimbursement claims can take a large share of a settlement if they are not handled. When a health plan paid your bills and you have a lawyer, Civil Practice and Remedies Code section 140.005 generally limits the plan’s recovery to the lesser of one half of your gross recovery or the benefits it paid, each reduced by a share of attorney’s fees and costs, though self-funded employer plans may follow federal law instead. Medicare is a secondary payer under 42 U.S.C. 1395y(b)(2) and must be repaid for conditional payments. Hospital liens are another layer. Each one is negotiated or calculated before the money is distributed.
For example, suppose an insurer offers $50,000 on a claim where the at-fault driver has a $50,000 policy, the injured person’s health plan paid $15,000 of medical bills, and a doctor has recommended a future procedure. The offer equals the policy limit, so more money from that driver’s insurer is not available without a larger exposure argument, and the next question is whether the injured person’s own underinsured motorist coverage can add to it. The health plan’s share would be capped by section 140.005 and reduced for fees and costs. Whether the result is fair depends on the cost of the future procedure and the rest of the losses. The numbers are hypothetical and are not a prediction for any case.
Can you get more than the at-fault driver’s policy? Sometimes. Underinsured motorist coverage under Insurance Code section 1952.106 pays what you are legally entitled to recover beyond the at-fault driver’s coverage, up to your UIM limit. The Texas Supreme Court held in Brainard v. Trinity Universal Insurance Co. (2006) that a UIM insurer owes nothing until the other driver’s liability and underinsured status are established, so these claims take documentation and sometimes a lawsuit. Your policy may also require you to notify your insurer before accepting the at-fault driver’s limits.
What about interest and timing? If the claim goes to judgment, past damages can earn simple prejudgment interest under Finance Code section 304.104, beginning on the earlier of 180 days after the defendant receives written notice of the claim or the date suit is filed. Future damages do not earn prejudgment interest. That rule affects how both sides view time, but it is not a reason to settle before your medical picture is clear.
Mistakes that cost people money
- Evaluating the offer before treatment ends.
- Comparing the offer to someone else's case instead of your own losses.
- Forgetting liens and reimbursement claims when calculating the net.
Related questions
Can I negotiate an insurer's first offer?
Yes. First offers are a starting point, and a counteroffer supported by records is normal.
What if my damages exceed the policy limits?
Look to your own underinsured motorist coverage and any other liable party or policy.
Is the settlement taxable?
Compensation for physical injuries is generally not federal taxable income; interest and punitive damages usually are.
How much of a $50,000 settlement will I actually get?
It depends on the fee percentage in your written fee agreement, case expenses, and what is owed to health plans, Medicare, or hospitals. Texas limits many health plan reimbursement claims under Civil Practice and Remedies Code section 140.005, and those amounts are often negotiated before money is distributed. Ask for a written settlement statement showing each deduction.
Should I accept the first settlement offer from the insurance company?
Not before your treatment is complete or your doctor can describe your future care. Accepting means signing a release that ends the claim, even if your condition later turns out to be worse.
What if the insurance company offers the policy limits?
A limits offer means that policy has nothing more to give. Before accepting, check whether your own underinsured motorist coverage or another party can add to the recovery, and whether your policy requires notice to your insurer first.
Do I have to pay my health insurance back out of my settlement?
Often, yes, if the plan paid your crash-related bills. For many plans, Texas law caps the reimbursement at the lesser of half your recovery or what the plan paid, reduced by a share of fees and costs, but self-funded employer plans and Medicare follow federal rules.
Sources



