Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code section 41.0105 limits recovery of medical expenses to the amount actually paid or incurred by or on behalf of the injured person. When health insurance pays a reduced rate, the recoverable amount is usually the reduced figure, not the full list price. Owsley Law Firm builds medical damages carefully and charges no fee unless we win.
Hospital bills often show a high list price. Health insurers then negotiate that down. Section 41.0105 decides which number counts in a Texas injury claim: the amount actually paid or incurred.
The rule affects how medical damages are calculated and how they are proven. It also affects people without insurance, people treated under a letter of protection, and people with liens. This page explains how.
What does the paid or incurred rule mean?
You can recover only the medical expenses actually paid or incurred by you or on your behalf, not amounts written off by a provider.
The rule affects negotiation as much as trial. Adjusters often value medical damages using the paid amounts, and they will ask for health insurance payment records to do it. Organizing those records early, with a clear summary of what was paid, what is still owed, and what future care is expected, makes the medical portion of the claim harder to discount.
If a hospital billed $40,000 and your health insurer’s contract reduced it to $12,000, the recoverable amount is generally what was paid or still owed, not the original charge. Amounts the provider wrote off and will never collect are not recoverable.
What if I did not have health insurance?
Charges you still owe are incurred expenses, so the amount of the bill you remain responsible for can be recovered if it is reasonable.
Uninsured patients often receive care billed at full rates. Because the patient owes those amounts, they are incurred. The reasonableness of the charges can still be disputed.
How are medical expenses proven in Texas?
Usually through billing records and affidavits from providers, which the defense can challenge with counter-affidavits.
Texas procedure lets providers submit affidavits stating that charges were reasonable and the services necessary. The process has deadlines, and missing them can affect what evidence comes in. That is part of why medical records are collected early.
- Itemized bills from each provider
- Records of payments by health insurance
- Remaining balances you owe
- Provider affidavits on reasonableness and necessity
Does the rule affect future medical costs?
Future care is proven with medical opinions and cost estimates, since it has not yet been paid or incurred.
Surgery recommendations, therapy plans, and life care plans support future medical damages. These require a physician’s opinion that the care is reasonably probable.
What about Medicare and Medicaid payments?
Amounts paid by Medicare or Medicaid are paid or incurred amounts, and those programs usually have reimbursement rights from the settlement.
Government health programs pay set rates, so the recoverable medical expense is generally what they paid. Federal law gives Medicare a right to be repaid from an injury recovery for related care, and state law gives Medicaid similar rights.
These claims must be identified and resolved before money is distributed. Failing to address them can create problems for both the injured person and the settling parties.
How does the rule interact with liens and reimbursement?
Hospital liens, health plan reimbursement claims, and Medicare or Medicaid interests often attach to the settlement and must be resolved.
A hospital lien under Property Code Chapter 55 can attach to the claim. Health plans may assert reimbursement rights. Resolving these correctly affects how much money reaches the injured person.
How it is proven after a crash
- Itemized medical bills
- Explanation of benefits from health insurers
- Provider billing affidavits
- Records of unpaid balances
- Physician opinions on future care
Mistakes that cost people money
- Assuming the full list price is recoverable
- Missing affidavit deadlines
- Ignoring liens until settlement
- Stopping treatment early to save money
Frequently asked questions
Does the paid or incurred rule limit pain and suffering?
No. Section 41.0105 applies to medical or health care expenses. Pain, mental anguish, physical impairment, and lost income are proven separately and are not limited by it.
Can I recover the full hospital bill in Texas?
Only the amount actually paid or incurred. Amounts written off by the provider are not recoverable.
Does health insurance reduce my settlement?
It often reduces the recoverable medical expense figure, but other damages like pain and lost income are separate.
What if I was treated under a letter of protection?
Charges you owe under the letter are incurred, though the defense may challenge their reasonableness.
Do I have to repay my health insurer?
Often, if the plan has reimbursement rights. Those claims are reviewed before settlement.
How long do I have to file?
Generally two years from the crash under section 16.003.
This page is general information about Texas law and is not legal or medical advice. Every case depends on its own facts. Contact the firm for a free review of yours.
Keep reading
