Quick answer

Not by itself. Texas law allows recovery for the aggravation of a preexisting condition. The insurer will argue your pain is old, and the answer is medical records that show the change the crash caused.

The rule is that a negligent driver takes the injured person as they find them. If a crash makes a bad back worse, the driver is responsible for the worsening, even if a healthier person would have walked away.

Insurers use prior conditions to argue the current complaints are old. The response is a comparison: records before the crash showing the baseline, and records after showing the change, ideally with a treating physician’s opinion tying the change to the crash.

Do not hide prior injuries. They will be found in records, and concealment damages credibility far more than the condition does.

Owsley Law Firm handles these cases regularly and builds them on the medical comparison, with no fee unless it wins.

Hand holding a phone at roadside showing a photo of a crash scene

Texas pattern jury charges address preexisting conditions directly. Jurors are told to consider the harm caused by the occurrence and not to include any amount for a condition that existed before it, except to the extent the occurrence aggravated it. This means the claim is for the difference, and the challenge is to prove how large the difference is.

The insurer's tools are records requests and independent medical examinations. Insurers seek years of prior records and look for any earlier complaint about the same body part. A prior treatment history is not fatal. Many people have degenerative changes that were not painful or limiting until the crash, and a doctor can explain how the crash turned an asymptomatic condition into a symptomatic one.

Imaging can cut both ways. A scan showing degeneration may be used to argue the pain is old, while a comparison to earlier images or a change in findings can support the crash's role. A treating physician's opinion, stated with reasonable medical probability, is the standard Texas courts require for causation on medical questions.

Be complete with your prior history. Tell your doctors and your lawyer about earlier injuries, even minor ones, because they will find them. A claimant who discloses and explains prior problems is credible, while one who conceals them gives the insurer an argument that reaches every part of the case.

How does a preexisting condition claim work step by step in Texas? It usually starts with the before picture: records from the doctors, chiropractors, or clinics that treated the same body part in the years before the crash. Next come the after records, beginning with the first visit following the crash. The treating doctor then compares the two and, if the facts support it, explains what changed and why the crash is the likely reason. That comparison becomes the center of the demand and, if a lawsuit is filed, the center of the medical testimony.

Why does a doctor’s opinion carry so much weight here? The Texas Supreme Court said in Guevara v. Ferrer (2007) that the general rule has long been that expert testimony is necessary to establish causation as to medical conditions outside the common knowledge and experience of jurors. A preexisting condition is the clearest case for that rule, because the insurer’s whole argument is that something other than the crash explains the symptoms. Your own description of how you feel matters, but separating old pain from new pain is usually a medical question.

What happens to your medical records if a lawsuit is filed? Under Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 194, a person who sues for physical injury must provide, without waiting for a request, the medical records and bills reasonably related to the injuries claimed, or an authorization that lets the other side get them. The rule is tied to records reasonably related to the injuries asserted, which is one reason the scope of a prior-history request is worth negotiating rather than granting without limits. The defense can also ask the court to order an examination by a physician under Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 204, but the rule requires a motion, good cause, and a physical condition that is actually in controversy.

Proving the bills is a separate step from proving the cause. Civil Practice and Remedies Code section 18.001 allows an affidavit from a provider or its records custodian to support a finding that the charges were reasonable and the services necessary, unless the other side serves a proper counteraffidavit. The same statute says that affidavit is not evidence of causation. In a preexisting condition case, that means the treatment bills can be supported by paperwork, but the link between the crash and the worsening still has to come from the medical evidence.

For example, suppose a 52-year-old warehouse worker had occasional lower back stiffness and saw a chiropractor a handful of times three years before a rear-end crash, then had no treatment at all until the collision. After the crash, the worker has pain running into one leg, misses shifts, and an MRI shows a disc problem along with age-related changes. The insurer will point to the old chiropractic visits and the degeneration. The worker’s side of the case is the long gap without treatment before the crash, the new leg symptoms that appear nowhere in the old records, the missed work, and a treating doctor’s opinion about what changed. This illustration is hypothetical and says nothing about what any particular claim is worth.

A few edge cases change the analysis. If you were still actively treating for the same body part on the day of the crash, the baseline is harder to draw and the doctor’s explanation has to be more specific. If you had another accident after this one, the insurer will argue that the later event caused part of the harm, so records from both need to be sorted out. And fault is a separate question from causation: under Chapter 33 of the Civil Practice and Remedies Code, a preexisting condition does not make you partly responsible for the crash, though the medical evidence still decides how much of your current condition the crash caused.

Mistakes that cost people money

  • Telling your doctor you have never had back or neck problems when you have.
  • Failing to gather prior records that show a stable baseline.
  • Assuming a prior injury means you have no claim.
  • Skipping follow-up care, which makes the change from baseline hard to prove.

Related questions

More on this topic.

What if my earlier injury was in a different accident?

The insurer will look at the earlier claim and treatment. If you recovered and were symptom-free, that helps. If not, a doctor needs to explain what this crash added, and the earlier records need to be reviewed.

Does arthritis or degeneration hurt my claim?

Not automatically. Many people have age-related changes without symptoms, and a crash can make them painful. The claim depends on medical proof that the crash aggravated the condition.

Will the insurer see all my medical records?

Insurers request broad authorizations, but you do not have to give unlimited access. Records are usually limited to relevant body parts and time periods, and a lawyer should manage what is released.

Can the insurance company make me see their doctor?

The other driver’s insurer can ask, but it cannot simply order an exam. Once a lawsuit is filed, the defense can move for an examination under Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 204, and the court may order one only for good cause when your physical condition is in controversy. Your lawyer can address the timing, scope, and conditions of any exam.

Do I have to tell the adjuster about my old injury?

You should never deny or misstate a prior injury. You also do not need to give the other driver’s insurer an open-ended medical history over the phone. The safer course is to let your lawyer provide the relevant prior records in an organized way, together with your doctor’s explanation of what changed.

What if I never told my doctor about my prior injury?

Tell your doctor now, and tell your lawyer. A causation opinion is only as strong as the history it rests on, and an opinion formed without knowing about the old injury can be attacked once the prior records surface.

Is a case with a preexisting condition worth less?

Not necessarily. The claim is for the harm the crash caused, including the worsening of a condition you already had, and a person with a vulnerable back can be hurt more by the same impact. What changes is the proof required, not the right to recover.

Sources

Sources this page relies on

  1. Texas Rules of Civil Procedure (Supreme Court of Texas)
  2. Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 18.001
  3. Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code ch. 33