Treat the claim as an uninsured motorist claim until proven otherwise. Texas requires every driver involved in a collision to show valid proof of financial responsibility, police can check coverage through the state’s TexasSure verification program, and your own uninsured motorist and PIP coverage can pay if the other driver had no real policy.
Transportation Code section 601.053 requires the operator of a vehicle to provide evidence of financial responsibility, such as an insurance card or policy, to a peace officer or to a person involved in a collision with the operator, on request. Operating without the required coverage is an offense under section 601.191. A card that turns out to be expired, cancelled, or invented does not satisfy the law.
You usually discover the problem when the insurer named on the card says there is no policy, or the policy was cancelled before the crash. Ask the police to verify coverage at the scene. Law enforcement can check whether a vehicle has the required coverage through TexasSure, the state’s financial responsibility verification program. The officer’s report should note what proof was shown.
Your own policy is the backstop. Texas insurers must offer uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage with every auto policy, and you have it unless you rejected it in writing under Insurance Code section 1952.101. Personal injury protection, offered under section 1952.152 at a minimum of $2,500 per person, pays medical bills and lost income regardless of fault. Notify your insurer promptly, because the policy sets notice requirements for uninsured motorist claims.
Other coverage may still exist. The vehicle’s owner may carry a valid policy even if the driver produced a fake card, and an employer may be responsible if the driver was working. The license plate and vehicle identification number are the starting point for finding the registered owner.
Sometimes the problem is not fraud but a lapse. A policy cancelled for nonpayment a week before the crash leaves the driver uninsured just the same. The insurer named on the card can usually confirm the cancellation date, and that date decides whether coverage existed at the moment of the crash.
Photograph the card, the driver’s license, the plate, and the vehicle at the scene. Owsley Law Firm traces the coverage, handles the uninsured motorist claim with your insurer, and charges no fee unless it wins.
What to do, step by step
- Photograph the insurance card, license, and plate.
- Ask police to verify coverage and note it in the report.
- Call the insurer on the card to confirm the policy.
- Notify your own insurer of a possible uninsured motorist claim.
- Check whether the vehicle owner has separate coverage.

A fake or lapsed policy is common enough that insurers have procedures for it. Your uninsured motorist claim is a claim against your own insurer, but the insurer still evaluates fault and damages, so it is handled like any other injury claim.
Providing false insurance information can lead to separate consequences for the other driver, but those do not pay your bills. Your coverage does.
An uninsured motorist claim is still a claim with an adversary. Your insurer can dispute fault and the value of the injuries, and the policy may require consent before you settle with anyone else. Read the uninsured motorist section of your policy and keep every letter your insurer sends.
Who has to prove the other car was uninsured? Insurance Code section 1952.109 puts the burden of proof on the insurer in a dispute over whether a motor vehicle is uninsured. That matters when a card turns out to be fake or the named company says it has no policy. You still need to cooperate and share what you have, such as the photo of the card, the crash report, and any letter from the company named on the card, but your own insurer cannot simply insist that you prove a negative.
What if the insurance company on the card is real but cannot pay? Insurance Code section 1952.102 says that, subject to the terms of the coverage, an uninsured motor vehicle includes an insured vehicle whose liability insurer is unable to pay because of insolvency. So uninsured motorist coverage can apply not only when there was no policy at all, but also when the at-fault driver’s insurer has failed. The policy language controls the details, so read the definitions section of your own policy.
Can the state take action against the uninsured driver? Chapter 601 of the Transportation Code has a safety responsibility process. Under Transportation Code section 601.152, the Department of Public Safety must suspend the driver’s license and vehicle registrations of an owner or operator involved in a collision when it finds a reasonable probability of a judgment against that person, unless the person deposits security and files proof of financial responsibility under section 601.153. The process applies only to crashes causing injury, death, or at least $1,000 in damage to one person’s property, and it does not apply to someone who had a liability policy in effect. Section 601.005 bars using those department actions as evidence of negligence in the civil case, so they do not prove your claim.
What happens after your own insurer pays? Insurance Code section 1952.108 gives an insurer that pays uninsured motorist benefits a right, to the extent of its payment, to the proceeds of any settlement or judgment against the person legally responsible. In plain terms, your insurer may pursue the uninsured driver after paying you. That is one reason not to sign any release with the other driver without telling your insurer first, since a release can interfere with that right and with your coverage.
What about the damage to your car? If you bought uninsured motorist property damage coverage, Insurance Code section 1952.105 says it is subject to a $250 deductible. Under section 1952.107, if you have both collision and uninsured motorist property damage coverage, you may choose which one to use, and if neither alone covers all the damage, you may use both, designating one as primary and paying its deductible. Comparing the two deductibles before filing can save money.
For example, suppose a driver on Interstate 45 in north Houston changes lanes into your car, then hands over a card showing a policy number with a familiar company. When you call, the company says the policy was cancelled for nonpayment two weeks before the crash. You photograph the card, ask for the crash report, and notify your own insurer of an uninsured motorist claim the same week, sending the cancellation information. Your insurer then evaluates fault and damages as it would any claim. This illustration is hypothetical and is not a prediction of any result.
Which edge cases come up? Sometimes the driver did have insurance, but on a different car, or was specifically excluded from the policy on the car they were driving. Whether any policy responds then depends on that policy’s terms, so the owner’s policy, the driver’s own policy, and any employer coverage should all be checked. If the driver left before you could get any information, the rules change: for an unknown driver, Insurance Code section 1952.104 requires actual physical contact between the vehicles for uninsured motorist coverage to apply.
Mistakes that cost people money
- Waiting to tell your insurer about the fake card.
- Settling with anyone without checking your policy’s consent requirements.
- Assuming no coverage exists anywhere.
- Not getting the vehicle’s plate and VIN.
Related questions
Will my rates go up for an uninsured motorist claim?
The Texas Department of Insurance says insurers may raise rates after accidents, so ask your insurer how it treats claims you did not cause.
What if I rejected uninsured motorist coverage?
A written rejection removes that coverage. Personal injury protection, if not rejected, still pays some medical bills and lost income.
Can I sue the driver personally?
Yes, but an uninsured driver often has little to collect, which is why your own coverage usually matters most.
How do I check if someone’s car insurance is valid in Texas?
Call the company on the card with the policy number and the date of the crash, and ask the officer at the scene to note what proof was shown. Information in the state’s verification program is confidential under Transportation Code section 601.454 and may be used only for authorized purposes, so it is not a public lookup tool.
Who has to prove the other driver was uninsured?
Under Insurance Code section 1952.109, the insurer has the burden of proof in a dispute about whether a vehicle is uninsured. You should still give your insurer everything you have, such as the card, the report, and any letter from the company named on it.
Can an uninsured driver lose their license after a crash in Texas?
Yes. Under Transportation Code section 601.152, the Department of Public Safety must suspend the license and registrations of an uninsured owner or operator when it finds a reasonable probability of a judgment, unless the person posts security and proof of financial responsibility. An unpaid judgment can also lead to suspension under section 601.332.
Is driving without insurance a crime in Texas?
Operating a vehicle without the required coverage is an offense under Transportation Code section 601.191, with a fine of $175 to $350 for a first conviction. That penalty does not pay your bills, which is why your own coverage matters.
Sources
Sources this page relies on
- Tex. Transp. Code § 601.053
- Tex. Ins. Code § 1952.101
- Tex. Ins. Code § 1952.152
- Tex. Ins. Code § 1952.109
- Tex. Ins. Code § 1952.102
- Tex. Transp. Code § 601.152
- Tex. Transp. Code ch. 601
- Tex. Ins. Code § 1952.108
- Tex. Ins. Code § 1952.105
- Tex. Ins. Code § 1952.104
- Tex. Transp. Code § 601.454
- Tex. Transp. Code § 601.191




