Quick answer

Sometimes. Texas allows exemplary (punitive) damages when a driver or company acted with gross negligence, malice, or fraud, proven by clear and convincing evidence and found by a unanimous jury. They are usually capped, but the cap does not apply to intoxication assault or intoxication manslaughter.

Ordinary carelessness is not enough. Civil Practice and Remedies Code section 41.003 allows exemplary damages only if the claimant proves fraud, malice, or gross negligence by clear and convincing evidence, and only if the jury is unanimous on both liability for and the amount of those damages.

Gross negligence has a two-part definition in section 41.001: an act involving an extreme degree of risk, viewed objectively, and the defendant's actual awareness of that risk combined with conscious indifference to others' safety. Drunk driving, extreme racing, and a trucking company knowingly putting a dangerous or exhausted driver on the road are the kinds of facts that can meet it.

Texas caps exemplary damages in most cases. Under Civil Practice and Remedies Code section 41.008, they cannot exceed the greater of two times economic damages plus noneconomic damages up to $750,000, or $200,000. The jury is not told about the cap.

Drunk driving crashes are a major exception. Section 41.008(c) removes the cap when the punitive claim is based on conduct described as intoxication assault or intoxication manslaughter under the Penal Code. A criminal conviction is not required to bring the civil claim, though a criminal case can produce useful evidence.

Punitive damages are taxable in a way that injury compensation generally is not, and they are hard to collect from an individual without assets. Owsley Law Firm evaluates every source of recovery, including employers and bars, and charges no fee unless it wins.

Traffic light at a rainy Houston intersection

Punitive damages against a company require proof about the company's own conduct, not just the driver's. The Texas Supreme Court explained in Mobil Oil Corp. v. Ellender (1998) that a corporation can be grossly negligent through a vice principal, such as an officer or a manager with authority to hire, direct, and fire employees, for example by putting a driver on the road it knew was dangerous.

Bars and restaurants can also be responsible under the Texas dram shop law when they served an obviously intoxicated person who then caused a crash, which can add a source of recovery beyond the drunk driver.

Because the cap is not disclosed to the jury, the verdict and the final judgment can differ. The court applies the cap after the verdict when it applies.

How is a punitive damages claim tried in Texas? On a defendant’s motion, Civil Practice and Remedies Code section 41.009 requires a bifurcated trial. In the first phase, the jury decides liability for both compensatory and exemplary damages and the amount of compensatory damages. Only if the jury finds liability for exemplary damages does a second phase decide how much. Evidence that bears only on the amount of punitive damages, such as a company’s net worth, stays out of the first phase under section 41.011.

What does the jury consider in setting the amount? Section 41.011 lists the factors: the nature of the wrong, the character of the conduct, the degree of culpability of the wrongdoer, the situation and sensibilities of the parties, the extent to which the conduct offends a public sense of justice and propriety, and the defendant’s net worth. Net worth is not automatically available. Under section 41.0115, a court may allow discovery of net worth only after finding, in a written order, that the claimant has shown a substantial likelihood of success on the exemplary damages claim.

What evidence tends to prove gross negligence in a crash case? It is usually evidence about what the defendant knew. In a drunk driving case: blood alcohol results, bar receipts, and witness accounts of how much was consumed. In a trucking case: hours-of-service records under 49 CFR Part 395, prior safety violations, a driver’s history of crashes or failed tests, and internal emails showing the company knew of a problem. Phone records can show a driver texting at highway speed. The common thread is proof of an extreme risk and actual awareness of it, which is the definition in section 41.001.

Are there other limits besides the cap? Several. Section 41.004 allows exemplary damages only if the jury awards damages other than nominal damages, so there must be real compensatory harm first. Section 41.006 requires an award against multiple defendants to be specific to each one, and each defendant is liable only for its own share. Section 41.007 bars prejudgment interest on exemplary damages. These rules shape how a claim is pleaded and presented from the start.

For example, suppose a jury finds a driver grossly negligent and awards $100,000 in economic damages and $50,000 in noneconomic damages. Under section 41.008, the cap is the greater of two times economic damages plus noneconomic damages up to $750,000, which here is $250,000, or $200,000. So any exemplary award above $250,000 would be reduced to $250,000 when the court enters judgment, unless the claim is based on conduct like intoxication assault or intoxication manslaughter that removes the cap. The numbers are hypothetical and show only how the formula works.

What protects a gross negligence claim early? Preservation. The evidence that proves what a driver or company knew is often in the defendant’s hands: dash cam footage, dispatch messages, maintenance files, and driver qualification records. Motor carriers must keep hours-of-service records and supporting documents for six months under 49 CFR 395.8(k), so a written preservation request should go out well before that window closes. The Texas Supreme Court explained in Brookshire Brothers v. Aldridge (2014) that a party who fails to preserve evidence it should have kept can face remedies in court, and a prompt letter makes that duty hard to dispute.

How do insurers treat punitive claims? Adjusters generally value a case on compensatory damages, and some policies do not cover punitive damages, so a punitive claim can matter most where a defendant has assets or a company is involved. A credible gross negligence claim can still affect how an insurer views trial risk, because it opens the door to evidence about the defendant’s conduct in the second phase. Whether a particular policy covers exemplary damages depends on its language and Texas law, and it should be checked rather than assumed.

Mistakes that cost people money

  • Assuming a criminal conviction is required before a civil claim can be filed.
  • Overlooking employer, owner, or bar liability that can matter more than the driver's assets.
  • Waiting on the criminal case while the two-year civil deadline runs.

Related questions

More on this topic.

Is a DWI crash automatically gross negligence?

Not automatically, but intoxicated driving is often strong evidence of it, and intoxication assault or manslaughter removes the cap.

Who pays punitive damages?

The defendant whose conduct justified them. Some insurance policies do not cover them, which affects collection.

Do I have to prove more than for regular damages?

Yes. Clear and convincing evidence and a unanimous jury are required.

What is the difference between punitive and exemplary damages in Texas?

They are the same thing. Texas statutes use the term exemplary damages in Chapter 41 of the Civil Practice and Remedies Code, and punitive damages is the common name for them.

Can you get punitive damages from a trucking company in Texas?

Possibly, if the company itself was grossly negligent, for example by keeping a driver on the road it knew was unsafe. The proof has to reach the company’s own conduct through a vice principal, and on a defendant’s motion the amount is decided in a separate phase of trial.

Is there a cap on punitive damages for a drunk driving crash in Texas?

Not when the claim is based on conduct described as intoxication assault or intoxication manslaughter under the Penal Code. Section 41.008(c) removes the cap for those, while most other punitive awards remain capped.

Do punitive damages earn interest before judgment?

No. Civil Practice and Remedies Code section 41.007 says prejudgment interest may not be assessed or recovered on an award of exemplary damages.

Sources

Sources this page relies on

  1. Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 41.003
  2. Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 41.008
  3. Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 41.009
  4. 49 C.F.R. Part 395 (hours of service)
  5. Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code ch. 41
  6. Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 41.007