If the other driver caused it, the claim runs against that driver as usual, and your own policy’s PIP and uninsured motorist coverage generally still apply. The rental company itself is usually not liable for the renter’s driving under the federal Graves Amendment, but it can be liable for its own negligence, such as a poorly maintained car.
Being in a rental car does not change who caused the crash. If another driver ran a light or rear-ended you, you claim against that driver’s liability insurance, and your own auto policy’s personal injury protection and uninsured motorist coverage typically follow you into a rental car, subject to the policy’s terms. Credit card rental benefits usually cover damage to the rental car, not your injuries.
Federal law shields rental companies from being sued simply because they own the car. The Graves Amendment, 49 U.S.C. section 30106, says a company in the business of renting or leasing vehicles is not liable for harm caused by the renter’s use of the vehicle solely because it owns it, as long as there is no negligence or criminal wrongdoing on the company’s part.
That exception matters. A rental company that rented a car with worn tires, failed brakes, or an open safety recall, or that ignored a known defect, can be liable for its own negligence. Maintenance and recall records for the vehicle become important, and the car should not be repaired or returned to service until it is inspected.
If you caused the crash in a rental, the people you hurt look to the coverage that applies to you as the driver, which usually starts with your own auto policy and may include any liability coverage you bought at the counter. Rental agreements also create damage claims for the car itself, loss of use, and administrative fees.
Tourists and visitors to Texas face these issues often, especially around airports in Houston, Dallas, and Austin. A visitor who leaves Texas after the crash can still pursue the claim here, and Texas law governs a crash on a Texas road. Medical treatment back home should be documented and connected to the crash in the same way.
Keep the rental agreement, photos of the car, and every document the company sends. Owsley Law Firm sorts out the coverage on each side and charges no fee unless it wins.
What to do, step by step
- Call the police and get a report number.
- Photograph the rental car and the scene.
- Notify the rental company as the agreement requires.
- Notify your own auto insurer.
- Keep the rental agreement and any coverage you bought.

Rental agreements often require you to report a crash to the company quickly and to cooperate with its claims process. Read the agreement and keep copies of everything you send.
If you were a passenger in a rental car driven by someone else, you may have claims against the driver’s coverage and your own policy’s PIP benefits.
Business travelers have another layer. If you rented the car for work, your employer’s coverage or a corporate rental agreement may apply, and a work trip can raise workers’ compensation questions.
What should happen in the first days after a rental car crash? The steps overlap with a crash in your own car, with a few additions. Under Transportation Code section 550.026, a crash with an injury, a death, or a vehicle that cannot be normally and safely driven must be reported to the police right away. The rental agreement usually sets its own reporting rule, so notify the company the way the contract says, and ask for its incident or claim number and the car’s unit number. Notify your own insurer as well, because its personal injury protection, medical payments, and uninsured motorist coverage may be the first money available for medical bills.
Which coverage pays for your injuries? Start with the at-fault driver if someone else caused the crash, then look at your own policy. Insurance Code section 1952.151 defines personal injury protection as paying the named insured and household members for reasonable medical expenses and lost income from an accident, incurred within three years, and Texas policies include it unless it was rejected in writing. The Texas Department of Insurance tells renters that PIP or medical payments coverage on their auto policy will cover their injuries, and that health insurance can cover some of the cost. TDI also describes credit card rental coverage as secondary, meaning the renter’s own auto policy is used first. A renter who owns no car and has no auto policy may have only the counter coverage they bought, health insurance, and the claim against the other driver.
What does the Graves Amendment leave open? The statute, 49 U.S.C. section 30106, protects a rental company only when it is in the trade or business of renting or leasing vehicles and there is no negligence or criminal wrongdoing on its part. It also says it does not override state laws that impose financial responsibility or insurance standards on vehicle owners. A separate federal rule matters for maintenance claims. Under 49 U.S.C. section 30120(i), a rental company that receives a safety recall notice generally may not rent the affected vehicle until the defect is remedied, after a short compliance window. If a recalled part played a role in the crash, the recall and repair history of that specific car becomes evidence of the company’s own conduct.
How do the insurers and the rental company handle the claim? Expect more than one adjuster. The rental company or its claims vendor usually pursues the renter for damage to the car, loss of use, and fees under the agreement, while the at-fault driver’s insurer handles the injury claim. Statements to any of them about how the crash happened may reach the others, so stick to facts and do not guess about speed or distance. When another driver caused the crash, that driver’s insurer is generally responsible for the damage to the rental car too, and the renter can send the rental company’s itemized claim to that insurer rather than paying it out of pocket first.
For example, suppose a visitor from another state lands at Bush Intercontinental Airport, rents a sedan, and is hit on the way into Houston by a driver who runs a red light. The visitor’s claim for medical care and lost income runs against the red-light driver’s liability insurer. The visitor’s own auto policy back home may provide medical payments or similar benefits, depending on its terms, and the rental company will look to someone for the damage to its car. If the sedan had an open safety recall on a part involved in the crash that was never repaired, the company’s own conduct could become part of the case. Each of these questions turns on the specific policies and evidence. This illustration is hypothetical and is not a prediction of any result.
Which situations complicate a rental car claim? A driver who was not listed on the rental agreement may face coverage questions under both the contract and their own policy, so the two documents need to be read together. A car rented from an individual through a peer-to-peer platform raises a different question: the Graves Amendment protects owners engaged in the trade or business of renting or leasing vehicles, and the platform’s insurance terms control much of the coverage. And a passenger hurt in a rental car who claims against the driver of that car should expect the driver’s insurer to take an offset for any PIP it paid, under Insurance Code section 1952.159.
Mistakes that cost people money
- Assuming the rental company will handle your injury claim.
- Relying on credit card coverage for injuries.
- Returning the car before photographing it.
- Not reporting to your own insurer.
Related questions
Is the rental company responsible for my injuries?
Usually not just because it owns the car, under the Graves Amendment, but it can be liable for its own negligence such as poor maintenance.
Does my own insurance cover a rental car?
Many personal auto policies extend coverage to rental cars, but the policy terms control. Check before relying on it.
Who pays for damage to the rental car?
Depending on fault and coverage, the other driver’s insurer, your policy, a damage waiver you bought, or a credit card benefit may pay.
Should I buy the rental company’s insurance in Texas?
It depends on what you already have. The Texas Department of Insurance suggests calling your agent to see what your auto policy covers in a rental, notes that using your own policy means paying your deductible, and says buying the rental company’s coverage may make sense if you have no auto insurance.
Does my credit card cover injuries in a rental car accident?
Usually not. Card benefits generally focus on damage to the rental car, and the Texas Department of Insurance describes card coverage as secondary to your own auto policy. Injuries are paid through the at-fault driver, your PIP or medical payments coverage, and health insurance.
Can I sue the rental car company if the car malfunctioned?
Possibly. The Graves Amendment does not protect a rental company from its own negligence, such as renting a car with a known defect or an unrepaired safety recall. Keep the car from being repaired or resold until it is inspected, and ask for its maintenance and recall records.
What should I do if the rental company sends me a bill after the crash?
Do not pay it right away. Ask for an itemized claim with the repair estimate and how loss of use and fees were calculated, then send it to your own insurer and, if another driver caused the crash, to that driver’s insurer. Coverage you bought at the counter or a card benefit may also apply, depending on their terms.
Sources




