No, not before you talk to a lawyer. You must report the crash to your own insurer, but nothing requires you to give the other driver’s adjuster a recorded statement, and those statements are used to reduce what you are paid.
Adjusters call within a day or two, sound sympathetic, and ask to record a short statement to “process the claim.” The statement is not for your benefit. Questions about speed, what you saw, whether you were hurt, and whether you had prior injuries are designed to produce a percentage of fault under Texas proportionate responsibility rules and a reason to discount the injury.
Your obligations run to your own insurer under your policy: report the crash promptly and cooperate. Those obligations do not extend to the other driver’s carrier.
If you already gave a statement, do not panic. Tell your lawyer exactly what was asked and answered. Early statements can be explained, and the physical evidence and medical records usually matter more.
Owsley Law Firm handles every communication with the insurers once retained, so clients never speak to an adjuster again. The consultation is free and there is no fee unless the firm wins.
What to do, step by step
- Report the crash to your own insurer promptly and factually, as your policy requires.
- When the other driver's adjuster calls, ask for the adjuster's name, company, and claim number, and say you will call back.
- Do not agree to record, sign a medical authorization, or discuss injuries, speed, or fault on that call.
- Write down what was asked and when, and keep any letter or email the adjuster sends.
- Hand the communication to your lawyer, who takes over all contact with the insurer.

Texas is a one-party consent state for recording under Penal Code section 16.02, so a call can lawfully be recorded with only the adjuster's knowledge, and you should assume any call to an insurer is being recorded whether or not you are told. What matters is not the legality of the recording but how the words are used later, quoted back in a demand response or at a deposition.
It also helps to understand who owes you what. Your own insurer owes you duties under your policy and under Insurance Code Chapter 541, which prohibits unfair settlement practices toward its insureds. The other driver's insurer owes you no duty of good faith. The Texas Supreme Court held long ago that a third-party claimant cannot sue the at-fault driver's insurer for bad faith in handling the claim, so its adjuster is negotiating against you, not for you.
The one obligation you do have is cooperation with your own carrier, and that is best met by giving it the facts in writing or through your lawyer. An insurer that needs a statement from you to pay a first-party claim, such as personal injury protection, can be given one with your lawyer present or after preparation.
The practical result of declining the other side's statement is small. The adjuster still has the police report, the photographs, and the medical records once you authorize a limited release. What the adjuster loses is a recorded admission, which is the thing the request was designed to get.
What happens step by step when the other driver’s insurer asks for a statement? Usually the adjuster calls, confirms a few basic facts, and then asks permission to record. You can decline and ask for the adjuster’s name, company, and claim number. The investigation does not stall without you: the Texas Department of Insurance explains that adjusters may inspect the damage, look at police reports, and talk to witnesses. Once you have a lawyer, the adjuster is told to direct all contact there, and the facts can be presented in a letter that has been checked against the crash report and photographs.
What happens to a recorded statement later? It becomes evidence. Under Texas Rule of Evidence 801(e)(2), a party’s own statement offered against that party is not hearsay, so your words can be played or read to a jury if the case is tried. Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 192.3(h) treats a recording of a person’s oral statement, or a substantially verbatim transcription of it, as a discoverable witness statement, and Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 194 requires parties in a lawsuit to disclose witness statements without being asked. If you already gave a statement, those rules mean your lawyer can obtain a copy and see exactly what was said.
Why does the medical authorization matter as much as the statement? Adjusters often send a records release along with the request to record. Under the federal HIPAA privacy rule, 45 CFR 164.508, a valid authorization must describe the information to be disclosed in a specific way and include an expiration date or event, and you can revoke it in writing at any time, except to the extent a provider has already acted on it. A broad, open-ended form lets an insurer gather records that have nothing to do with the crash. A narrower authorization, limited to the providers who treated you and a reasonable period before the crash, gives the adjuster what it needs to evaluate the injury.
How do insurers use a statement once they have it? The same way they use the rest of the claim file. A recorded answer that you felt fine at the scene, or a guess at your speed, can be quoted later to argue a lower value or a share of fault. Under Chapter 33 of the Civil Practice and Remedies Code, any percentage of responsibility assigned to you reduces your recovery, and more than 50 percent bars it. A recorded statement is also hard to walk back, because a later correction can be framed as a changed story.
For example, suppose a driver is rear-ended on the Southwest Freeway and the next morning gets a call from the other driver’s insurer. She is sore but has not seen a doctor, and on a recorded line she says she feels okay, just stiff. Two days later her neck pain worsens and her doctor orders an MRI. The adjuster may later point to her words to argue the injury is minor or came from something else. Had she declined and seen a doctor first, the claim would rest on the medical records rather than on a remark made before she knew what was wrong. This illustration is hypothetical and does not predict how any claim would turn out.
What if the caller is your own insurer? Then the cooperation duties in your policy apply, and the request deserves a careful, prepared response rather than a refusal. That includes a personal injury protection claim, which Insurance Code section 1952.156 requires your insurer to pay no later than the 30th day after it receives satisfactory proof of the claim. It also includes an uninsured or underinsured motorist claim, where your own company evaluates fault and damages much as the other driver’s insurer would. In that setting it is reasonable to give the statement with your lawyer present or after preparing with them.
Mistakes that cost people money
- Saying you are fine or okay on a recorded line before you have been examined.
- Guessing at speeds, distances, or times instead of saying you do not know.
- Signing a broad medical authorization that lets the insurer search years of unrelated records.
- Assuming a friendly tone means the adjuster is on your side.
Related questions
Can the other insurer force me to give a statement?
No. There is no Texas rule that requires you to give the at-fault driver's insurer a recorded statement. You can decline politely and refer the adjuster to your lawyer, and the claim will still move forward on the documents.
What if my own insurer asks for a statement?
Your policy requires cooperation, so you should respond. It is reasonable to have your lawyer present or to give the statement in writing, and to answer only what is asked about the crash itself.
Is a written statement safer than a recorded one?
Not automatically. A written statement can be just as damaging and is harder to correct. Whatever form it takes, it should be reviewed by a lawyer before anything goes to the other side's insurer.
Do I have to give a recorded statement to the other driver’s insurance in Texas?
No. You have no contract with the other driver’s insurer, and no Texas law requires you to give it a recorded statement. The Texas Department of Insurance points out that you do not have the same options with another driver’s company that you have with your own, which is one more reason to keep communication factual and in writing.
Can I get a copy of the recorded statement I gave the insurance company?
In a lawsuit, yes. Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 192.3(h) lets any person obtain, on written request, their own statement concerning the lawsuit that a party holds, and Rule 194 requires parties to disclose witness statements. Before a suit is filed, ask the adjuster for a copy in writing.
Can I take back a medical authorization I signed for the insurance company?
Generally yes. Under the federal HIPAA rule, 45 CFR 164.508, you can revoke an authorization in writing at any time, though revoking it does not undo disclosures a provider already made in reliance on it. Send the revocation to the insurer and to each provider.
What should I say if the adjuster calls before I have a lawyer?
Keep it short. Confirm your name and contact information, decline to be recorded, and say you will respond in writing. Do not describe your injuries, guess at speeds or distances, or agree that you are fine.
Sources



