Quick answer

It helps, but it is separate. A criminal charge against the driver who hurt you is the state’s case, decided under a stricter standard; your injury claim is a civil case for money damages that you control. A conviction can support your claim, restitution may cover some losses, and you do not have to wait for the criminal case to end.

When the other driver is charged with driving while intoxicated, intoxication assault, failure to stop and render aid, or another offense, the prosecutor represents the State of Texas, not you. The criminal case asks whether the state proved guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. Your civil claim asks whether the driver was negligent by a preponderance of the evidence, a lower standard, and it seeks payment for medical bills, lost income, pain, and the other damages Texas law allows.

The two cases interact. Police reports, blood test results, video, and witness statements gathered by investigators can be valuable evidence in the civil claim. A guilty plea can be used as the driver’s own statement, and a felony conviction, such as intoxication assault, can be admitted when Texas Rule of Evidence 803 allows it. A plea of no contest, however, cannot be used against the driver in a civil case under Texas Rule of Evidence 410.

Criminal courts can order restitution. Code of Criminal Procedure article 42.037 allows the sentencing court to order a convicted defendant to pay restitution to a victim. Restitution is usually limited to specific losses and is no substitute for a full civil recovery. Separately, the Crime Victims’ Compensation Act in Code of Criminal Procedure chapter 56B can help pay certain expenses when a crash involved conduct it covers, such as intoxication assault, intoxication manslaughter, or failing to stop and render aid.

Intoxication cases can also change damages. Chapter 41 of the Civil Practice and Remedies Code caps exemplary damages, but section 41.008(c) removes the cap for conduct that is a felony such as intoxication assault or intoxication manslaughter.

The driver’s criminal lawyer may advise the driver not to answer questions in the civil case while charges are pending, and courts sometimes pause parts of a civil case because of that. Early steps, such as notifying insurers, preserving evidence, and documenting injuries, can still move forward. In many cases the liability insurer resolves the civil claim regardless of the criminal timeline.

You do not need to wait for a verdict, and the two-year civil deadline keeps running while the criminal case proceeds. Owsley Law Firm represents injured people in their civil claims only, works alongside the criminal process, and charges no fee unless it wins.

What to do, step by step

  1. Keep every document from the prosecutor’s office.
  2. Write down hearing dates and outcomes.
  3. Notify the at-fault driver’s insurer of your claim.
  4. Apply for crime victims’ compensation if the conduct qualifies.
  5. Talk to a lawyer about the civil claim right away.
Empty hospital waiting room with rows of chairs

The criminal case can provide evidence you could not easily get yourself, such as toxicology results and accident reconstruction by police. Your lawyer can request those records as the case allows.

Victims also have rights in the criminal process, including notice of hearings and the chance to give a victim impact statement. Those rights are separate from the civil claim.

The defendant’s insurer still handles the civil claim. Criminal charges do not usually stop a liability insurer from paying for a covered driver’s negligence, and in serious cases the insurer may want to resolve the civil claim. A lawyer can coordinate the timing so the criminal case does not delay your recovery unnecessarily.

Which criminal outcomes can be used in the civil case? The Texas Rules of Evidence draw specific lines. Texas Rule of Evidence 410 bars, in a civil case, a guilty plea that was later withdrawn, a no contest plea, statements made in proceedings on those pleas, and statements made in plea discussions with the prosecutor that did not end in a guilty plea. A final judgment of conviction is admissible in a civil case under Texas Rule of Evidence 803 only if it followed a trial or guilty plea rather than a no contest plea, the conviction was for a felony, it is offered to prove a fact essential to the judgment, and no appeal is pending. A first driving while intoxicated offense is usually a Class B misdemeanor under Penal Code section 49.04, while intoxication assault is a third degree felony and intoxication manslaughter is a second degree felony. A guilty plea that stands is not on Rule 410’s excluded list, and a party’s own statement offered against them is not hearsay under Texas Rule of Evidence 801.

How does restitution interact with the civil claim? Under Code of Criminal Procedure article 42.037, when an offense causes personal injury, the sentencing court may order the defendant to pay the victim’s expenses incurred as a result of the offense. The court may not order restitution for a loss the victim has received or will receive compensation for only from another source, other than the crime victims’ compensation fund. Any amount the victim later recovers from the same person in a civil case is reduced by restitution already paid. The article also says a conviction estops the defendant from denying the essential allegations of the offense in a later civil case brought by the victim, to the extent consistent with state law, and a restitution order can be enforced like a civil judgment.

When does crime victims’ compensation cover a crash? The program in Chapter 56B of the Code of Criminal Procedure generally excludes conduct arising from the use of a motor vehicle, with listed exceptions: conduct intended to cause injury or death, violations of the move over law or reckless driving under Transportation Code sections 545.157 and 545.401 that cause bodily injury or death, failing to stop and render aid under section 550.021, and offenses including manslaughter, criminally negligent homicide, aggravated assault, deadly conduct, driving while intoxicated, intoxication assault, and intoxication manslaughter. An application generally must be filed within three years of the conduct, though the attorney general may extend that for good cause. Awards generally may not exceed $50,000 in the aggregate, with up to $75,000 more for catastrophic injury that causes total and permanent disability, and the program pays only for losses not compensated from a collateral source as the statute defines that term.

For example, suppose a driver is arrested for driving while intoxicated after rear-ending a car at a red light in Pasadena, and the other driver goes to the emergency room. The defendant later pleads no contest to misdemeanor DWI. Under Rule 410, that plea cannot be used against him in the civil case, so the injured driver’s claim relies on the officer’s observations, video, the blood test result, and witnesses. If the criminal court orders restitution for the emergency room bill and the defendant pays it, any later civil recovery from him is reduced by that amount under article 42.037. The injured driver may also apply for crime victims’ compensation because DWI is a listed offense. This illustration is hypothetical and does not predict any result.

Does a death change the interaction? Civil Practice and Remedies Code section 71.006 says a wrongful death action is not precluded because the death was caused by a felonious act or because there may be a criminal proceeding. Families do not have to choose between supporting a prosecution and pursuing the civil claim. In a death case, the timing differences matter even more: the criminal case can take a long time, while the two-year civil deadline and any government notice deadline keep running.

Mistakes that cost people money

  • Waiting for the criminal case to end before acting on the civil claim.
  • Assuming restitution will cover your losses.
  • Talking to the defendant’s insurer before consulting a lawyer.
  • Missing the two-year civil deadline while the criminal case is pending.

Related questions

More on this topic.

Do I have to testify in the criminal case?

You may be subpoenaed as a witness by the prosecution. That is separate from your civil claim, though what you say can matter in both.

Can I sue if the driver was found not guilty?

Yes. The civil case uses a lower standard of proof, and an acquittal does not decide it.

Is a DWI conviction proof of fault in my civil case?

Not by itself. A guilty plea can be used as the driver’s own statement, and a felony conviction can be admitted under Texas Rule of Evidence 803, but a first DWI is a misdemeanor, so the civil case usually relies on the underlying evidence: the stop, the test results, and the video. A no-contest plea cannot be used against the driver under Texas Rule of Evidence 410.

Is a no contest plea an admission of guilt in a Texas civil case?

No. Texas Rule of Evidence 410 says a no contest plea is not admissible against the defendant in a civil case. The civil claim is proved with the underlying evidence instead.

Does restitution reduce my injury settlement?

Under Code of Criminal Procedure article 42.037, any amount you recover from the same person in a civil case is reduced by restitution that person already paid you. The civil claim remains available, with restitution credited against it.

Can the criminal court order the driver to pay my medical bills?

When an offense causes personal injury, the sentencing court may order restitution for expenses the victim incurred as a result of the offense, under article 42.037. The amount and timing are set by the criminal court.

How do I apply for crime victims’ compensation after a DWI crash?

The program is administered by the Texas Attorney General under Chapter 56B of the Code of Criminal Procedure. DWI is a listed offense, and an application generally must be filed within three years of the crash.

Sources

Sources this page relies on

  1. Texas Rules of Evidence (Supreme Court of Texas)
  2. Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code ch. 41
  3. Tex. Penal Code § 49.04
  4. Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 71.006