Ask for the denial and its reason in writing, then match the response to the reason. A liability denial by the other driver’s insurer is answered with evidence or a lawsuit against the driver. A denial by your own insurer is governed by Insurance Code deadlines and can support extra damages if it was unreasonable.
Start by finding out who denied the claim and why. The answer decides the next step, because Texas treats your own insurer and the other driver’s insurer very differently.
When the at-fault driver’s carrier denies, the usual reasons are disputed fault, a claim that your injuries were not caused by the crash, or a coverage problem such as an excluded driver or lapsed policy. That insurer owes you no contractual duty: in Allstate v. Watson (1994) the Texas Supreme Court held a third-party claimant cannot sue the other driver’s insurer for unfair claim handling. The remedy is to prove the claim, with photos, witnesses, video, and medical opinions, or to sue the driver, which the insurer must then defend.
When your own insurer denies a PIP, uninsured or underinsured motorist, or collision claim, the Insurance Code applies. Chapter 542 requires an insurer to acknowledge and begin investigating a claim within 15 days of notice (section 542.055) and to accept or reject it in writing within 15 business days after receiving the items it requested (section 542.056). Section 542.060 adds interest and attorney’s fees when an insurer that owes a claim violates those rules, and section 541.151 allows suit for unfair practices.
Uninsured and underinsured motorist claims have a special rule: under Brainard v. Trinity Universal (2006), the insurer does not owe benefits until the other driver’s liability and the amount of your damages are established, so these denials are often a step in the process rather than the end.
A denial is frequently an opening position. Owsley Law Firm reviews the letter, the policy, and the evidence at no charge, and handles the response or the lawsuit on contingency.
What to do, step by step
- Ask for the denial and the specific reason in writing.
- Get a copy of your policy and any reservation of rights letter.
- Gather evidence that answers the reason given.
- Respond in writing and keep proof of every submission.
- Call a lawyer before the two-year deadline under section 16.003 approaches.

Some denials are really a request for more information. Section 542.055 lets an insurer request the items it reasonably believes it needs, and providing them starts the 15 business day decision period under section 542.056.
A denial based on causation, that the crash did not cause your injury, is usually answered with treating doctor opinions and records showing when symptoms began.
Coverage denials raise different questions. If the insurer says the driver was excluded from the policy, the policy lapsed, or the car was being used for business, ask for the policy language it relies on. Some exclusions hold up and some do not, and a lapsed policy may leave your own uninsured motorist coverage as the right source.
Keep a written timeline. Note when you reported the claim, when the insurer acknowledged it, what it requested, and when you provided it. Those dates are what determine whether an insurer followed the deadlines in Chapter 542, and they are much easier to prove from your notes than from memory.
What does a proper denial from your own insurer have to say? For a claim under your own policy, Insurance Code section 542.056 requires the insurer to tell you in writing whether it accepts or rejects the claim, and a rejection must state the reasons. If the insurer cannot decide within the 15 business day window, it must tell you within that same window why it needs more time, and then decide no later than 45 days after that notice. Separately, Insurance Code section 541.060 lists unfair settlement practices, including failing to promptly give a policyholder a reasonable explanation of the basis in the policy, in relation to the facts or law, for a denial; failing to affirm or deny coverage within a reasonable time; and refusing to pay a claim without a reasonable investigation. A one-line denial that cites no policy language is worth questioning in writing.
How do you answer a denial, step by step? First, identify which policy and which coverage the denial concerns, and ask for a complete copy of the policy with every endorsement. Second, match the stated reason to evidence: a fault dispute calls for the crash report, photos, video, and witness statements; a causation dispute calls for treating doctor records and opinions; a coverage dispute calls for the exact policy wording. Third, send a written response that attaches that evidence and asks the insurer to reconsider, and keep proof of delivery. Fourth, calendar the deadlines that keep running no matter what the insurer does: two years under Civil Practice and Remedies Code section 16.003 to sue the at-fault driver, and two years under Insurance Code section 541.162 for an unfair practices claim against your own insurer.
What can you recover if your own insurer handled the claim unfairly? A policyholder who prevails under Chapter 541 of the Insurance Code can recover actual damages, court costs, and reasonable and necessary attorney’s fees under Insurance Code section 541.152, and if the jury finds the insurer acted knowingly, it may award up to three times actual damages. Before filing, section 541.154 generally requires written notice at least 61 days in advance describing the complaint and the damages. A policy also cannot shorten the time to sue on it below two years: Civil Practice and Remedies Code section 16.070 makes a contractual limitations period shorter than two years void. None of this runs against the other driver’s insurer, because section 541.060(b) gives no cause of action to a third party asserting a claim against someone covered by a liability policy.
How do uninsured motorist denials usually play out? A common reason given is that the other vehicle was not really uninsured, for example because a policy turned up later. Insurance Code section 1952.109 puts the burden of proof on the insurer in a dispute over whether a vehicle was uninsured. In a hit-and-run, the insurer may point to the actual physical contact requirement in Insurance Code section 1952.104, so evidence of contact, such as paint transfer, damage photos, and a police report describing the impact, matters. If a lawsuit becomes necessary, Insurance Code section 1952.110 limits where a UM or UIM coverage suit can be filed: the county where the policyholder lived at the time of the accident or the county where the accident happened.
For example, suppose a Houston driver is sideswiped by a car that leaves the scene, and her own insurer denies her uninsured motorist claim in a short letter saying there is no proof the other car touched hers. Her response would start with the evidence of contact: photos of the scraped door showing another vehicle’s paint, the police report, and any witness or camera footage. She would also ask the insurer to identify the policy language and facts it relied on, and keep a dated record of every call and letter. Whether the denial is reversed depends on the evidence and the policy terms. This illustration is hypothetical and is not a prediction of any result.
Which denials need special care? A PIP denial has its own statute: Insurance Code section 1952.156 requires payment no later than 30 days after satisfactory proof, and section 1952.157 adds a 12 percent penalty, interest, and attorney’s fees when PIP is not paid on time. A UIM denial that comes after you settled with the at-fault driver raises the consent-to-settle question, and in Hernandez v. Gulf Group Lloyds (1994) the Texas Supreme Court held that an insurer can avoid coverage under a settlement-without-consent exclusion only when it was actually prejudiced by the settlement. And a reservation of rights letter is not a denial; section 541.060 expects an insurer to affirm or deny coverage, or reserve its rights, within a reasonable time.
Mistakes that cost people money
- Assuming the denial is final.
- Arguing by phone without written records.
- Missing your own policy’s notice or proof-of-loss deadlines.
- Settling with the at-fault driver without your insurer’s consent when a UIM claim is possible.
Related questions
Can I file a complaint with the state?
Yes. The Texas Department of Insurance accepts consumer complaints about insurers, and a complaint can prompt a response, though it does not decide the claim.
How long does an insurer have to decide?
For first-party claims, 15 business days after it receives the items it requested, under section 542.056, with some extensions allowed by statute.
Can I sue the other driver’s insurer for denying me?
Not for unfair handling. Allstate v. Watson holds a third-party claimant has no such claim; the suit is against the at-fault driver.
How long do I have to sue my insurance company for denying my claim in Texas?
For an unfair settlement practices claim, Insurance Code section 541.162 sets two years from the act or from when it was or should have been discovered. A policy cannot set a deadline to sue on it shorter than two years, under Civil Practice and Remedies Code section 16.070. Other claims can have different timing, so have the dates reviewed early.
Does a denial letter have to explain the reason?
For a claim under your own policy, yes. Insurance Code section 542.056 requires a written rejection to state its reasons, and section 541.060 treats a failure to promptly give a reasonable explanation of the policy basis for a denial as an unfair settlement practice.
What if my insurer says the other driver was not uninsured?
Insurance Code section 1952.109 puts the burden of proof on the insurer in a dispute over whether the other vehicle was uninsured. Ask in writing for the coverage information it found, including the company name and policy number, and check it.
Can I make the other driver’s insurer reconsider a denial?
You can ask, by sending evidence that answers its stated reason, such as video, witness statements, or a doctor’s causation opinion. That insurer has no contract with you, so the real pressure is the claim against its driver, and filing suit against the driver within two years is what keeps that claim alive.
Sources
Sources this page relies on
- Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 16.003
- Tex. Ins. Code ch. 541
- Tex. Ins. Code ch. 542
- Tex. Ins. Code § 542.056
- Tex. Ins. Code § 541.060
- Tex. Ins. Code § 541.162
- Tex. Ins. Code § 541.152
- Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 16.070
- Tex. Ins. Code § 1952.104
- Tex. Ins. Code § 1952.109
- Tex. Ins. Code § 1952.110
- Tex. Ins. Code § 1952.156



