With timing. Pin down the exact moment of the crash, then match it to the driver's phone activity from carrier logs, account data, or a court-ordered device exam, backed by witnesses and video. Texas bans reading, writing, or sending messages while driving under Transportation Code section 545.4251.
Start with what the law prohibits. Transportation Code section 545.4251 makes it an offense to use a portable wireless device to read, write, or send an electronic message while operating a motor vehicle unless the vehicle is stopped. The statute lists affirmative defenses, including hands-free use, navigation, reporting illegal activity or summoning help, reading a message reasonably believed to concern an emergency, a device affixed to the vehicle to communicate with a dispatcher or work app, and activating music. Expect the driver to claim one of them. Proof needs to show messaging, not just that a phone was on the seat or giving directions. A separate page covers phone use generally; this one is about building the texting proof.
Proving a texting violation can strengthen a claim, but it is not automatic liability. Texas courts sometimes treat violation of a safety statute as negligence per se, meaning the violation itself establishes a breach of duty, but whether a particular traffic statute qualifies is a legal question courts decide statute by statute, and some traffic rules have been held not to qualify. Either way, you still must prove the texting caused the crash. Even without a statutory violation, evidence that the driver was looking at a screen supports ordinary negligence, because every driver must keep a proper lookout. A citation for texting helps, but the absence of one does not end the claim.
The proof is a timeline. Fix the crash time as precisely as you can from 911 call logs, the vehicle's event data recorder, video timestamps, and the police report, then compare it with the phone's activity. Carrier records generally show the time of calls, texts, and data sessions, but federal law limits what a provider may hand over. The Stored Communications Act, 18 U.S.C. 2702, generally bars public providers from disclosing the contents of stored messages, while allowing non-content records to be disclosed to people other than the government. So a subpoena to a carrier usually yields logs rather than what was said. Message content and app activity typically come from the device itself or the driver's own accounts.
Getting into the phone itself is harder. In In re Weekley Homes (2009), the Texas Supreme Court called direct examination of a party's electronic device particularly intrusive and required a specific request under Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 196.4, a showing that the other side has not met its own duty to search and produce, a showing that the examination could recover relevant information, protections for privacy, and benefits that outweigh the burden. When that showing is made, courts can order a limited examination for a window around the crash. The process takes time, which is why a preservation letter should go out early, telling the driver and any employer not to delete messages, reset, trade in, or replace the phone. Destroying that evidence after notice can carry consequences.
People and cameras often supply the first proof. Witnesses may have seen the driver looking down, the glow of a screen at night, or a phone in hand right after impact. Write down their names and what they said while memories are fresh, and ask the officer to note any admission. Dashcams, rideshare and delivery driver cameras, traffic cameras, and business video can show head position and the absence of braking. For commercial drivers, federal rules separately prohibit texting while driving a commercial motor vehicle and bar carriers from allowing it (49 CFR 392.80), so the carrier's policies and records also come into play. Owsley Law Firm pursues phone evidence in distracted driving crashes and charges no fee unless it wins.
What to do, step by step
- Note the exact time of the crash and of your 911 call.
- Get names and statements from witnesses who saw the driver.
- Look for dashcam, business, and traffic camera video.
- Have a lawyer send a preservation letter covering the phone and accounts.

Drivers under 18 may not use a wireless device at all while driving in Texas, hands-free included, under Transportation Code section 545.424, which can simplify the proof when a teen driver was involved.
If the driver was working, the employer's phone policies, dispatch systems, and any company-issued device records can show activity at the time of the crash.
Mistakes that cost people money
- Assuming carrier records will show what the driver wrote.
- Waiting until the driver replaces the phone.
- Treating a missing texting citation as the end of the issue.
Related questions
Can I get the other driver's text messages?
Usually not from the carrier. Federal law generally bars providers from disclosing message content; content usually comes from the device or the driver's accounts through discovery.
Is hands-free texting legal in Texas?
Using a hands-free device is an affirmative defense under section 545.4251 for adult drivers.
Does texting make the driver automatically liable?
Not automatically. You still must prove it caused the crash.
Sources



