Quick answer

With records, not suspicion. Phone carrier records, app and device data, video, witness accounts, and the timing of the crash can show the driver was texting or using the phone. Those records are obtained through a preservation letter and legal process in the case, and Texas bans reading, writing, or sending electronic messages while driving.

Texas law makes phone use while driving relevant. Transportation Code section 545.4251 prohibits using a portable wireless communication device to read, write, or send an electronic message while operating a vehicle unless it is stopped. Commercial drivers face stricter federal rules: 49 CFR 392.80 prohibits texting while driving a commercial motor vehicle, and 392.82 prohibits using a hand-held mobile telephone.

The strongest proof is the phone’s own history. Carrier records show calls, texts, and data sessions with timestamps. Device data and app records can show typing, messaging, social media, or navigation activity. Matched against the crash time from the police report, 911 calls, and the vehicle’s event data recorder, those records can place the phone in use at the moment of impact.

Those records are not available on request. They are obtained through discovery and subpoenas once a claim is in litigation, often under a protective order. That is why a preservation letter matters early: it puts the driver and their carrier on notice not to delete or replace the phone or its data.

Other evidence fills in the picture. Witnesses often see a driver looking down. Dashcams, nearby business cameras, and traffic cameras may show it. The crash itself can be telling: no braking before a rear-end collision, drifting out of a lane, or failing to react to a light that changed seconds earlier. Police may note an admission or a phone found in the driver’s hand.

Hands-free use is a gray area under the statewide statute, which targets reading, writing, and sending electronic messages. Even when a driver’s phone use was technically legal, evidence that the driver was distracted can still support negligence, because every driver must keep a proper lookout and control of the vehicle.

Proving distraction can raise the value of a claim and affect fault. Owsley Law Firm sends preservation demands, pursues the records through the case, and charges no fee unless it wins.

What to do, step by step

  1. Write down anything you saw the driver doing.
  2. Get names of witnesses.
  3. Ask nearby businesses to keep video.
  4. Have a lawyer send a preservation letter covering the phone and its data.
  5. Request phone records through the case.
Aftermath of a rear-end collision on a freeway at dusk

Commercial drivers leave more evidence. Fleet telematics and in-cab cameras often record driver behavior, and federal rules prohibit hand-held phone use in commercial vehicles, so a trucking company’s own records can show distraction.

Your own phone matters too. Expect the defense to ask for your records, and be careful about what you say and post after a crash.

Timing analysis is often what wins these cases. Matching a text sent seconds before impact to the event data recorder’s record of no braking can show distraction more convincingly than any witness.

What does the Texas texting law cover, and what are its exceptions? Transportation Code section 545.4251 makes it an offense to use a portable wireless communication device to read, write, or send an electronic message while operating a vehicle unless the vehicle is stopped. The statute lists affirmative defenses, including use with a hands-free device, navigating with GPS, reporting illegal activity or summoning emergency help, reading a message the driver reasonably believed concerned an emergency, using a device affixed to the vehicle to communicate with a dispatcher for work, and activating music. Those defenses limit a criminal charge. They do not decide whether the driver was paying attention for purposes of a civil negligence claim.

Will the police report show phone use? Sometimes, but often not. Section 545.4251 says an officer who stops a vehicle for a texting violation may not take possession of or inspect the device unless authorized by other law, so a report may contain only what the officer saw or what the driver said. The penalties can be significant when someone is hurt: the offense is ordinarily a fine of $25 to $99, or $100 to $200 with a prior conviction, but it becomes a Class A misdemeanor, with a fine up to $4,000 and up to one year in jail, if the driver caused death or serious bodily injury. A civil claim does not depend on a ticket being written.

What can a phone carrier actually hand over? Federal law draws a line between content and records. Under the Stored Communications Act, 18 U.S.C. 2702, a provider of electronic communication service to the public generally may not divulge the contents of a stored communication, subject to listed exceptions such as consent. The same statute allows a provider to disclose non-content records about a customer to any person other than a governmental entity. That is why a civil case usually focuses on activity logs, meaning when calls, texts, and data sessions occurred, rather than on what a message said.

How are the records obtained step by step? First, a preservation letter goes to the driver, and to the employer if the driver was working. Second, once suit is filed, the driver is asked for phone records and data in discovery, and Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 196.4 requires electronic data to be specifically requested along with the form of production. Third, Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 205 lets a party compel documents from a nonparty, such as the carrier, by serving notice on everyone and a subpoena. Requests to inspect the phone itself are more contested than requests for logs, and under Rule 192.6 the court can limit discovery to protect against undue burden or invasion of personal rights.

How do insurers push back? Common responses are that the activity was hands-free or navigation, that a passenger was using the phone, that background app traffic created the data entries, or that the timestamps do not line up with the crash. Each is a timing and context question, which is why the records are compared with the crash time from the report, the 911 call log, and the vehicle’s event data. The driver’s own words also matter: under Texas Rule of Evidence 801(e)(2), a statement by a party offered against that party is not hearsay, so an admission at the scene can be used.

For example, suppose a driver stopped at a light on Kirby Drive is rear-ended, and the other driver tells the officer they glanced down for a second. The injured driver notes the comment, gets a witness’s number, and asks a lawyer to send a preservation letter covering the other driver’s phone. In a lawsuit, carrier logs showing a text sent shortly before the impact time, matched with event data showing no braking, would support the claim that the driver was distracted. This illustration is hypothetical and is not a prediction of any result.

Which edge cases come up most? If the driver was on a work call or messaging a dispatcher, the employer may also be responsible, and for commercial drivers 49 CFR 390.11 requires the carrier to make its drivers follow the federal phone rules. Teen drivers face a stricter rule: Transportation Code section 545.424 bars drivers under 18 from using a wireless communication device except in an emergency. And school crossing zones carry their own restriction under Transportation Code section 545.425 unless the vehicle is stopped or a hands-free device is used.

Mistakes that cost people money

  • Accusing the driver at the scene instead of documenting.
  • Failing to ask for a preservation letter early.
  • Not checking for nearby video.
  • Posting about the crash on social media.

Related questions

More on this topic.

Can I get the other driver’s phone records myself?

Usually not. Records are obtained through subpoenas or discovery once a claim is in litigation.

Is talking on the phone illegal while driving in Texas?

The statewide law bans reading, writing, or sending electronic messages while driving. Other phone restrictions apply in school zones and for commercial and new drivers.

Does proving texting increase my settlement?

It can, by strengthening fault and supporting arguments about the driver’s carelessness.

What if the driver denies using the phone?

Records usually decide it. Carrier and device data with timestamps are harder to dispute than testimony.

Do police check phones after a car accident in Texas?

Not routinely. Transportation Code section 545.4251 bars an officer who stops a vehicle for a texting violation from taking or inspecting the phone unless other law authorizes it. A report may still note what the officer saw or what the driver admitted.

Can I subpoena the other driver’s cell phone records in Texas?

Once a lawsuit is filed, yes, through discovery from the driver and a subpoena to the carrier under Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 205. Federal law generally limits carriers from disclosing message content, so the records usually show activity and timing rather than what was said.

Is using GPS while driving illegal in Texas?

Navigating with GPS is an affirmative defense to the texting offense under Transportation Code section 545.4251. That does not make every use safe: a driver who was distracted by a navigation screen can still be negligent in a civil claim.

What is the penalty for texting and driving in Texas if someone is hurt?

If the driver caused death or serious bodily injury, the offense under Transportation Code section 545.4251 is a Class A misdemeanor, punishable by a fine up to $4,000 and up to one year in jail. The civil injury claim is separate from any criminal case.

Sources

Sources this page relies on

  1. Tex. Transp. Code § 545.4251
  2. Texas Rules of Civil Procedure (Supreme Court of Texas)
  3. Texas Rules of Evidence (Supreme Court of Texas)
  4. Tex. Transp. Code § 545.424
  5. Tex. Transp. Code § 545.425