The at-fault driver’s insurer, under the property damage part of their liability policy. If fault is disputed or they are uninsured, your own collision coverage pays, less your deductible, and your insurer can recover from the other side. Texas law lets you choose the repair shop.
Texas is a fault state, so the driver who caused the crash is responsible for your repairs, and their liability insurance usually pays. Texas requires at least $25,000 in property damage coverage under Transportation Code section 601.072.
You have two paths. A third-party claim with the other driver’s insurer pays the full repair cost with no deductible, but only after that carrier accepts liability. A first-party claim under your own collision coverage pays faster, minus your deductible, and your insurer can then pursue the other carrier and often recover your deductible for you.
You choose the shop. Insurance Code section 1952.301 bars an insurer from limiting your choice of repair person or facility, and in a third-party claim it may not require you to use a particular shop. Section 1952.302 bars an insurer from telling you that you must use a shop on its preferred list for the repair to be covered.
If the other driver was uninsured, uninsured motorist property damage coverage, if you bought it, can pay, usually with a smaller deductible than collision. A hit-and-run raises a special issue: for property damage, Texas UM coverage generally depends on proof of the other vehicle, and Insurance Code section 1952.104 requires actual physical contact for an unknown driver.
Keep the estimate, photos, and invoices, and do not sign a release that covers more than property damage. Owsley Law Firm helps injured clients get the property claim paid while the injury claim moves forward.
What to do, step by step
- Report the claim to the at-fault driver’s insurer and your own.
- Choose your repair shop and get an estimate.
- Decide whether to use your collision coverage for speed or wait for the other carrier.
- Keep photos, estimates, and invoices.
- Ask your insurer to pursue your deductible from the other carrier.

Shops often find hidden damage after teardown. Insurers handle that through a supplement to the estimate, so tell the shop to request one if needed.
If repairs exceed the car’s value, the claim becomes a total loss and is valued at actual cash value instead.
Using your own collision coverage first is often faster, especially when fault is disputed. Your insurer pays, then pursues the other carrier through a process called subrogation. If it recovers, you typically get your deductible back, and using collision coverage for a crash you did not cause should not be treated as an at-fault claim, though practices vary by insurer.
When the property damage limit is small and several cars were damaged, the $25,000 minimum may be split among everyone. In that situation your own coverage becomes more important, and moving early on the claim can matter.
Towing and storage charges add up quickly. Move the car from a storage lot to your chosen shop as soon as you can, and ask the insurer in writing to approve the move. Daily storage fees that run while an insurer delays are part of the property claim.
Can you use both collision and uninsured motorist property damage coverage? Insurance Code section 1952.107 says an insured who has collision coverage and uninsured or underinsured motorist property damage coverage may recover under whichever one the insured chooses. If neither alone covers all the damage from one crash, the insured may use both, designating one as primary and paying that coverage’s deductible, and the primary coverage is used up first. The insured is not required to pay the second deductible when it is the same as or less than the first.
What is the deductible for uninsured motorist property damage? Insurance Code section 1952.105 says this coverage is offered subject to a $250 deductible, and in amounts no higher than the property damage liability limits on your policy. That is often lower than a collision deductible, so if the at-fault driver had no insurance, it is worth comparing the two before choosing which claim to file.
How is the value of a repair claim measured? Texas measures damage to a vehicle that can be repaired by the difference in value before and after the crash, or by the reasonable cost of repairs with due allowance for any difference between the original value and the value after repairs, plus loss of use, as the Texas Supreme Court has long held. In J&D Towing v. American Alternative Insurance (2016), the court held that loss of use is recoverable even when a vehicle is a total loss. When repair costs, not counting repainting and sales tax, exceed the actual cash value right before the crash, Transportation Code section 501.091 classifies the car as a salvage motor vehicle.
Can the body shop keep your car until it is paid? Yes. Property Code section 70.001 gives a worker who repairs a vehicle a lien that allows the shop to keep the car until the amount due under the repair contract is paid, or, if no amount was set, the reasonable and usual compensation. If the insurer’s payment falls short of the shop’s final bill, you may have to cover the difference before the car is released and then pursue it in the claim. Resolving supplements with the insurer before the work is finished avoids that surprise.
How do insurers handle the two kinds of repair claims? When your own insurer pays under collision coverage, the first-party prompt payment rules in Chapter 542 of the Insurance Code set deadlines for acknowledging, deciding, and paying. When the other driver’s insurer pays, those deadlines do not apply, although that company must still act in good faith. Insurance Code section 1952.305 requires notice of your repair rights when the vehicle is presented, and section 1952.306 lets a policyholder, third-party claimant, or repair shop file a written complaint with the Texas Department of Insurance about repair violations.
For example, suppose your car is rear-ended on Interstate 10 near downtown Houston, and the other driver’s insurer says it is still investigating fault. You file under your own collision coverage with a $500 deductible, take the car to the shop you choose, and the shop finds a damaged bracket after teardown and sends a supplement, which your insurer reviews. After paying, your insurer pursues the other carrier and, if it recovers, typically refunds your deductible. This illustration is hypothetical and is not a prediction of any result.
Which deadlines and edge cases apply? The deadline to sue for property damage is generally two years under Civil Practice and Remedies Code section 16.003, but your own policy requires prompt notice, so do not wait. Your own policy generally does not pay diminished value after a full and adequate repair, under American Manufacturers Mutual Insurance v. Schaefer (2003), so that part of the loss usually runs against the at-fault driver. If the car is financed or leased, the lender’s interest may need to be addressed in the payment, so tell the adjuster who holds the title at the start.
Mistakes that cost people money
- Letting an adjuster steer you to a shop you do not want.
- Accepting an estimate that omits hidden damage without a supplement.
- Signing a release that covers injuries.
- Forgetting rental and diminished value.
Related questions
Do I have to get three estimates?
Texas law does not require it. Insurers may inspect the car, but you choose where it is repaired.
Will I get my deductible back?
If your insurer recovers from the at-fault carrier, it typically refunds your deductible, in full or in proportion to its recovery.
Can the insurer use aftermarket parts?
Section 1952.301 bars insurers from limiting coverage by specifying the kind of parts that may be used, except as commissioner rules allow. Ask what parts are planned.
What if the shop finds more damage after it starts?
The shop requests a supplement from the insurer. Supplements are routine and should be approved when the damage is documented.
Should I use my own insurance or the other driver’s for repairs?
If fault is clear and the other insurer accepts liability quickly, a third-party claim avoids your deductible. If fault is disputed or the other insurer is slow, your collision coverage is usually faster, and your insurer can pursue the other carrier for its payment and your deductible.
Can the body shop hold my car if insurance does not pay the full bill?
Yes. Property Code section 70.001 lets a repair shop keep the vehicle until the amount due under the repair contract, or the reasonable and usual charge, is paid. Settle supplements with the insurer before pickup.
What is the deductible for uninsured motorist property damage in Texas?
Insurance Code section 1952.105 provides that the coverage is offered subject to a $250 deductible. Under section 1952.107, you can choose between it and collision coverage, or use both if neither covers everything.
How long do I have to file a property damage claim after a Texas car accident?
A lawsuit for property damage generally must be filed within two years under Civil Practice and Remedies Code section 16.003. Insurance policies require much faster notice, so report the claim to both insurers right away.
Sources


