Quick answer

Usually some of it. Most health plans have a right to repayment, but in Texas Chapter 140 of the Civil Practice and Remedies Code limits most insurers to the lesser of what they paid or half of your recovery, after a share of fees, when you have a lawyer. Medicare, Medicaid, and some employer plans follow federal rules.

When a health plan pays bills caused by someone else, the policy usually gives it a right to be repaid from your recovery. This is called subrogation or reimbursement, and it is one of the main reasons the amount you take home differs from the settlement amount.

Texas limits it. Chapter 140 of the Civil Practice and Remedies Code, in effect since 2014, applies to health and disability plans, including insurance companies and HMOs, but section 140.002 excludes self-funded plans governed by federal ERISA law. When you have a lawyer, section 140.005 limits all payors combined to the lesser of half of your gross recovery minus attorney’s fees and costs, or the benefits paid minus their share of fees and costs. Section 140.007 makes a plan that does not hire its own lawyer share in your attorney’s fees.

Federal programs work differently. Medicare has a statutory right to be repaid and must be addressed before funds are released. Medicaid has its own lien rights. Many large employers’ self-funded plans are governed by federal ERISA law, and Civil Practice and Remedies Code section 140.002 excludes those plans from the Texas limits, so the plan documents and federal law control their repayment claims.

Repayment is often negotiable, especially when liability coverage is small compared to the injuries. Plans will reduce claims to reflect the cost of recovery and the risks of trial.

Never ignore a repayment claim, because a plan can pursue you after the case closes. Owsley Law Firm identifies every payor early, applies Chapter 140 where it fits, and negotiates repayment so the final numbers are clear before you sign.

What to do, step by step

  1. Tell your lawyer every plan that paid bills: health, disability, Medicare, Medicaid.
  2. Get the plan’s itemized list of crash-related payments.
  3. Ask the plan for its policy or summary plan description.
  4. Apply Chapter 140 or federal rules as appropriate.
  5. Negotiate and get a final written payoff before closing.
Tow truck with flashing lights at a nighttime accident scene

Plans sometimes include payments for treatment unrelated to the crash. Reviewing the itemized list often lowers the amount owed.

Disability plans that paid wage benefits may also claim repayment, and Chapter 140 covers disability benefit plans as well.

Medicare repayment must be addressed before closing. Medicare’s recovery contractor issues a final demand after the settlement is reported, and waiting can add interest. Your lawyer reports the case, disputes unrelated charges, and pays the final amount from the settlement.

Medicaid has lien rights in Texas as well, and the amount can be reduced in some situations. As with any payor, the itemized list of payments is the starting point, and charges unrelated to the crash should be removed.

Ask your plan for its payment list early in the case rather than at the end. Knowing the repayment amount helps evaluate settlement offers, because what matters is what you keep after fees, costs, and repayment.

Which plans does Chapter 140 cover, and which does it not? Civil Practice and Remedies Code section 140.002 applies to health benefit plans, disability benefit plans, and employee welfare benefit plans issued by insurance companies, HMOs, and similar issuers, and to self-funded plans generally. The same section lists what it does not cover: workers’ compensation, Medicare, Texas Medicaid and Medicaid managed care, the state children’s health plan, and self-funded plans subject to the federal ERISA law. Sorting a plan into the right category comes first, because each category has different repayment rules.

Can a health plan take money from my own uninsured motorist or MedPay claim? Usually not, if the plan is covered by Chapter 140. Under section 140.008, a payor may not pursue a recovery against the covered person’s first-party recovery, and it may pursue uninsured or underinsured motorist coverage or medical payments coverage only if neither the covered person nor the person’s immediate family paid the premiums. That matters in Texas crash cases, where a large share of the money can come from the injured person’s own UM/UIM policy. Section 140.009 also confirms that a plan may waive, negotiate, or decide not to pursue its claim.

How do self-funded ERISA plans work? Their plan documents control. In US Airways v. McCutchen (2013), the U.S. Supreme Court held that when an ERISA plan seeks reimbursement under an equitable lien by agreement, the plan’s terms govern and general fairness doctrines cannot override them. When the plan is silent about attorney’s fees, though, the common fund doctrine fills the gap, so the plan shares in the cost of obtaining the recovery. That is why the summary plan description and the full plan document are requested early, and why the funding question decides whether Chapter 140 or the plan language applies.

What about Medicaid? Texas has its own statute. Under Human Resources Code section 32.033, applying for or receiving Medicaid assigns to the state the right to recover from a person who caused the injury, and a recipient must tell the Health and Human Services Commission about an unsettled injury claim within 60 days of learning of it. The state’s recovery is limited to the cost of the medical care it paid. The same section says an injury claim is not grounds for denying or ending Medicaid benefits, and it lets the state waive its recovery in whole or in part when enforcing it would defeat the purpose of public assistance.

How does the math work? For example, suppose a Houston driver covered by an insured (not self-funded) employer health plan settles a crash claim for $90,000, the plan paid $30,000 in crash-related bills, and the plan has no lawyer of its own. Under section 140.005(c), the plan’s share is the lesser of half the gross recovery or the benefits paid, each reduced by attorney’s fees and procurement costs under section 140.007. Because $30,000 is less than half of $90,000, the plan’s share starts from the $30,000 figure, minus its share of fees and costs, and without a fee agreement with the plan, the court sets that fee at a reasonable amount up to one-third of the plan’s recovery. The real numbers depend on the fee agreement, the costs, and negotiation. This illustration is hypothetical and is not a prediction of any result.

What happens at the end of the case? The goal is a final written payoff from every payor before the money is distributed. Plans often send updated payment lists late in the case, so the last itemization is compared with the medical records to remove care unrelated to the crash. Medicare reduces its recovery for procurement costs under 42 CFR 411.37, using the ratio of those costs to the total settlement. And if a disagreement with a Chapter 140 payor ends up in a declaratory judgment action, section 140.006 bars the court from awarding costs or attorney’s fees to any party, which encourages both sides to resolve it by agreement.

Mistakes that cost people money

  • Assuming a plan will not seek repayment.
  • Spending settlement money before the plan is resolved.
  • Accepting the plan’s list without removing unrelated charges.
  • Ignoring Medicare’s interest.

Related questions

More on this topic.

What does Chapter 140 limit?

With a lawyer, all payors combined recover the lesser of half your gross recovery minus fees and costs, or what they paid minus their share of fees and costs.

Does Chapter 140 apply to my employer’s plan?

It depends on how the plan is funded and whether federal ERISA law applies. The plan documents decide.

Can repayment be negotiated?

Yes. Plans often accept reductions, especially when liability coverage is limited.

Does my plan get repaid before my lawyer’s fee?

Under Chapter 140, a plan that does not hire its own lawyer shares in the attorney’s fees under section 140.007, which reduces what it collects.

Do I have to pay back my health insurance if I settle without a lawyer?

Often yes. When a person is not represented, section 140.005(b) limits all covered payors to the lesser of half of the gross recovery or the benefits paid, with no reduction for fees. The type of plan and its terms still matter.

Does Chapter 140 apply to Medicare or Medicaid?

No. Section 140.002 excludes Medicare, Texas Medicaid, Medicaid managed care, and the state children’s health plan. Medicare follows federal secondary payer rules, and Texas Medicaid recovers under Human Resources Code section 32.033, limited to what it paid.

Can my health insurer take money from my uninsured motorist claim?

Under section 140.008, a payor covered by Chapter 140 may pursue UM/UIM or medical payments coverage only if neither you nor your immediate family paid the premiums. A self-funded ERISA plan follows its own plan terms instead.

What is the made whole doctrine in Texas?

It is a common law rule that an injured person must be fully compensated before an insurer is repaid. For payors covered by Chapter 140, section 140.005(d) says it does not apply.

Sources

Sources this page relies on

  1. Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code ch. 140
  2. Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 140.002