Quick answer

With the other driver’s adjuster, say as little as possible: confirm your name and contact information, decline a recorded statement, and refer them to your lawyer. With your own insurer, report the crash promptly as your policy requires, stick to facts, and do not guess about fault or injuries.

The other driver’s adjuster works for the other driver’s insurance company. Their job is to resolve the claim for as little as possible, and early calls are often used to lock in statements that can be used later. You are not required to give them a recorded statement.

If you speak with them, keep it short. Give your name and contact information, confirm the date and place of the crash, and say you are still getting medical care. Do not describe your injuries in detail, do not say you are fine, do not guess at speeds or distances, and do not apologize, because it can be treated as an admission.

Your own insurer is different. Your policy requires you to report the crash and cooperate, and you may need your own coverage for personal injury protection, uninsured or underinsured motorist benefits, or collision repairs. Report the basic facts, but keep the same discipline about guessing and minimizing injuries.

Do not sign medical authorizations or releases without review. A broad medical authorization can give the insurer your entire medical history, and a release ends the claim permanently, even if your injuries turn out to be worse than you thought.

Texas does not require you to give the other driver’s insurer any statement at all. Your obligations run to your own insurer under your policy. If the other insurer insists, a short written notice that you are represented, or that you will provide information through counsel, is enough.

If the crash involved a commercial truck or a rideshare driver, there may be several insurers and adjusters calling at once. Each represents a different company with its own interests. Keep a list of who called and refer all of them to your lawyer.

Once a lawyer is involved, the adjuster deals with the lawyer instead of you. Owsley Law Firm takes over insurer communications from the start and charges no fee unless it wins.

Empty hospital waiting room with rows of chairs

Write down what you remember about the crash for your lawyer, not for the insurer. A private, dated account of what happened, your symptoms, and how your daily life has changed can be valuable later, and sharing it with your lawyer keeps it protected.

Be careful with property damage calls. Many people talk to the other insurer about repairs or a rental car while they are still hurt. It is fine to handle the vehicle claim, but keep those calls to the vehicle and do not discuss your injuries, treatment, or how the crash happened beyond the basic facts.

If an adjuster asks you to estimate your injuries or your recovery time, the honest answer is that your doctors have not finished evaluating you. That answer is true, and it avoids a statement that will be quoted back to you if the injury turns out to be more serious.

Adjusters often call within days, sometimes with a friendly tone and a quick offer. Early offers are made before the full medical picture is known, and accepting one usually requires signing a release that ends the claim.

Keep a log of every insurer contact: the date, the person’s name, and what was said. That record helps your lawyer and protects you if statements are later misquoted.

Can what you say to an adjuster be used in court later? Yes, and that is the reason for caution. Under Texas Rule of Evidence 801, a party’s own statement offered against that party is not hearsay, so a recorded comment about speed, distraction, or feeling fine can come in as evidence. Texas does protect simple sympathy: Civil Practice and Remedies Code section 18.061 bars a court from admitting an expression of sympathy or benevolence about someone’s pain or injury when offered to prove liability. But a statement that also concerns negligence or fault, such as an apology for not seeing the other car, is admissible.

Are settlement negotiations protected? Partly. Texas Rule of Evidence 408 bars evidence of offers to compromise a disputed claim, and statements made during compromise negotiations, from being used to prove or disprove the validity or amount of the claim. The court may still admit that evidence for another purpose, such as showing a witness’s bias. Rule 409 separately bars using an offer to pay medical expenses to prove liability. These rules protect the back-and-forth over money. They are not a reason to discuss how the crash happened with the other driver’s adjuster.

What should a medical authorization contain if you sign one? Federal privacy rules set the minimum. Under 45 CFR 164.508, a valid authorization must describe the information to be disclosed in a specific way, name who may disclose it and who may receive it, state the purpose, include an expiration date or event, and be signed and dated. It must also tell you that you can revoke it in writing, and you may do so at any time, except to the extent a provider has already relied on it. An authorization with no date limits and no list of providers reaches far beyond the crash, which is why many people let their lawyer gather and send the relevant records instead.

What rules govern your own insurer’s adjuster? Insurance Code section 541.060 lists unfair settlement practices for claims by an insured, including misrepresenting a material fact or policy provision, failing to promptly explain the basis for a denial or a compromise offer, failing within a reasonable time to accept or deny coverage, trying to enforce a full release when only part of a claim was paid, refusing to pay without a reasonable investigation, and, outside of lost income and a few other claims, demanding federal tax returns. The same section says it does not give a third party a cause of action against the other driver’s insurer, which is one reason calls with that adjuster call for extra care.

For example, suppose two days after a crash on Highway 290, the other driver’s adjuster calls, asks how you are feeling, and asks to record a short statement. You confirm your name and the date and place of the crash, say you are still being evaluated by your doctors, and decline to be recorded. The adjuster then emails a medical authorization with no expiration date covering all providers for all years. You do not sign it, and you send the claim number to your lawyer, who later provides records limited to the crash. This illustration is hypothetical and is not a prediction of any result.

What if the adjuster asks about prior injuries or your work? Answer through your lawyer, and answer truthfully. Prior injuries will appear in medical records, and an honest history that explains the change after the crash is stronger than a denial that is later contradicted. Questions about missed work are usually answered with a letter from your employer showing your pay and the days missed, not a phone conversation. If the call turns to whether you were partly to blame, end the conversation politely, because statements about fault are exactly what section 18.061 leaves admissible.

Mistakes that cost people money

  • Giving a recorded statement to the other driver’s insurer.
  • Saying you are fine before you have seen a doctor.
  • Signing a broad medical authorization.
  • Accepting a quick settlement check before knowing the extent of the injury.

Related questions

More on this topic.

Do I have to talk to the other driver’s insurer at all?

You are not required to give them a recorded statement. Your lawyer can handle communication.

What if the adjuster says the offer expires soon?

Pressure tactics are common. A short deadline is not a reason to accept an offer you have not evaluated.

Should I tell my own insurer I have a lawyer?

Yes. Your lawyer will notify them and coordinate any claims under your own policy.

Can an apology be used against me after a car accident in Texas?

Pure sympathy, such as saying you are sorry someone was hurt, is not admissible to prove liability under Civil Practice and Remedies Code section 18.061. An apology that admits fault, such as saying you did not see the other car, can be admitted.

Do I have to sign the insurance company’s medical authorization?

Nothing requires you to sign the other driver’s insurer’s form. If you sign any authorization, federal rules at 45 CFR 164.508 require it to have an expiration date or event and tell you that you can revoke it in writing.

Can my insurance company ask for my tax returns after a crash?

Insurance Code section 541.060 lists requiring tax returns as an unfair settlement practice, except when a court orders them, the claim involves a fire loss, or the claim involves lost profits or income. A lost wage claim may therefore involve tax records.

Are things I say during settlement negotiations admissible?

Offers and statements made in compromise negotiations cannot be used to prove or disprove the validity or amount of the claim under Texas Rule of Evidence 408, though a court may admit them for another purpose such as showing bias.

Sources

Sources this page relies on

  1. Texas Rules of Evidence (Supreme Court of Texas)
  2. Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 18.061
  3. Tex. Ins. Code ch. 541
  4. Tex. Ins. Code § 541.060