Under Civil Practice and Remedies Code section 41.003, except as provided by subsection (c), exemplary damages (often called punitive damages) may be awarded only if the claimant proves by clear and convincing evidence that the harm results from fraud, malice or gross negligence. Ordinary negligence is not enough. The jury must also be unanimous on liability for and the amount of exemplary damages.
Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code, Chapter 41 (Damages). Read section 41.003 and the definitions in section 41.001 in the Legislature's own text.
Most Texas crash claims ask for compensation for the harm a crash caused. Exemplary damages are different. They are an added award that Texas allows only in limited cases. Section 41.003 of the Civil Practice and Remedies Code sets the standard.
This page explains what the section says in plain words. It then shows how the rule connects to a motor vehicle injury claim: the kinds of proof involved, the jury vote, and how fault is shared. It does not cover the dollar limits on exemplary damages. Those are in the separate card on Civil Practice and Remedies Code section 41.008.
What does CPRC 41.003 say about exemplary damages?
Except as provided by subsection (c), exemplary damages may be awarded only if the claimant proves, by clear and convincing evidence, that the harm results from fraud, malice or gross negligence.
Subsection (a) says that, except as provided by subsection (c), exemplary damages may be awarded only if the claimant proves by clear and convincing evidence that the harm results from (1) fraud, (2) malice or (3) gross negligence. Subsection (b) says the claimant must prove the elements of exemplary damages by clear and convincing evidence.
Subsection (b) also says this burden of proof may not be shifted to the defendant or satisfied by evidence of ordinary negligence, bad faith or a deceptive trade practice. In a crash case, that means a plain mistake behind the wheel does not meet the standard by itself.

What is the difference between punitive and exemplary damages in Texas?
The Texas statute uses the term exemplary damages. People often say punitive damages when they mean the same kind of award.
Section 41.003 and the rest of Chapter 41 use the words exemplary damages. That is the term to look for when reading the law or a court charge.
Exemplary damages are separate from the damages that pay for losses such as medical bills. Section 41.004 says exemplary damages may be awarded only if damages other than nominal damages are awarded. So the claim for exemplary damages sits on top of a successful injury claim.
What counts as gross negligence after a car crash?
Gross negligence is more than carelessness. Section 41.001 defines it as an act or omission that involves an extreme degree of risk and that the actor knew about but ignored.
The definition has two parts. First, viewed objectively from the standpoint of the actor at the time, the act or omission involves an extreme degree of risk, considering the probability and magnitude of the potential harm to others. Second, the actor has actual, subjective awareness of the risk involved but nevertheless proceeds with conscious indifference to the rights, safety or welfare of others.
Malice is defined separately as a specific intent by the defendant to cause substantial injury or harm to the claimant. Fraud means fraud other than constructive fraud. Which facts fit these words in a given crash is a question for the court and the jury, and a lawyer can help weigh the facts.
- Ordinary negligence does not meet the standard.
- Gross negligence needs both an extreme risk and actual awareness of it.
- Malice needs a specific intent to cause substantial harm.
- The words are defined in section 41.001.
What does clear and convincing evidence mean?
It is a higher level of proof than a simple majority of the evidence. Section 41.001 defines it as proof that produces a firm belief or conviction about the truth of the allegations.
The statute defines clear and convincing as the measure or degree of proof that will produce in the mind of the trier of fact a firm belief or conviction as to the truth of the allegations sought to be established.
Under subsection (b), the claimant carries this burden. It is not shifted to the defendant. For a crash claim, that makes the quality of the proof important, as the table below shows.
Does the jury have to agree on exemplary damages?
Yes. Subsection (d) says exemplary damages may be awarded only if the jury was unanimous about liability for and the amount of exemplary damages.
Subsection (e) adds that when the issue goes to the jury, the court's charge must include an instruction that, to find exemplary damages, the answer to the question about the amount must be unanimous.
Section 41.006 adds that when there are two or more defendants, an award of exemplary damages must be specific to a defendant. Each defendant is liable only for the amount awarded against that defendant.

Does a different statute change the 41.003 standard?
Subsection (c) covers claims based on a statute that creates a cause of action and authorizes exemplary damages in set circumstances or with a set mental state.
In that case, subsection (c) says exemplary damages may be awarded only if the claimant proves by clear and convincing evidence that the damages result from the specified circumstances or culpable mental state.
That is why subsection (a) begins with the words except as provided by subsection (c). Whether a particular claim falls under subsection (c) is a question to take to a lawyer.
How does shared fault in a crash claim relate to exemplary damages?
Chapter 33 sets how fault is shared. Exemplary damages under section 41.003 ask a different question: whether the harm resulted from fraud, malice or gross negligence.
For a crash claim governed by Chapter 33, responsibility greater than 50 percent bars compensatory recovery. Otherwise, section 33.012(a) reduces that recovery by the claimant's percentage of responsibility. Section 33.002(c)(2) excludes the exemplary-damages claim from Chapter 33, so these percentage rules do not directly reduce exemplary damages. Section 41.004 separately requires an award of damages other than nominal damages before exemplary damages may be awarded. See the separate cards on Chapter 33 and responsible third parties for details.
Section 41.003 does not set those percentages. It sets the proof needed before exemplary damages can be awarded.
Section 41.003 elements and how each is proven after a crash
| Element or rule | What the statute says | How it can be shown after a crash |
|---|---|---|
| Fraud, malice or gross negligence | Harm must result from fraud, malice or gross negligence (41.003(a)) | Evidence of what the driver or company did and knew: crash report, photos, video, witness statements, records |
| Clear and convincing evidence | Proof that produces a firm belief or conviction (41.001) | Consistent, specific evidence from more than one source |
| Not ordinary negligence | Ordinary negligence does not satisfy the burden (41.003(b)) | Facts beyond a simple mistake, such as proof the driver knew of an extreme risk |
| Burden on the claimant | The burden may not be shifted to the defendant (41.003(b)) | The claimant carries the burden of proof |
| Unanimous jury | Jury must be unanimous on liability for and amount (41.003(d)) | Charge to the jury includes the unanimity instruction (41.003(e)) |
| Damages other than nominal | Exemplary damages need an award of damages other than nominal (41.004(a)) | Proof of the actual injuries and losses |
How it is proven after a crash
- The official crash report and the officer's narrative, if one exists.
- Photos and video of the scene, vehicles and road conditions.
- Names and contact details of witnesses.
- Phone, vehicle or company records that may show what a driver knew or did. Ask a lawyer promptly about requesting preservation; sending a request does not guarantee that records will be retained.
- Medical records and bills that show the harm.
Mistakes that cost people money
- Assuming any serious crash is gross negligence. The statute asks for actual awareness of an extreme risk.
- Thinking ordinary negligence is enough. Section 41.003(b) says it does not satisfy the burden.
- Waiting to save video, photos and records that can be lost over time.
- Posting about the crash online, where the posts may be used in the claim.
Related Texas laws
Where this fits in your claim
- 1. The crash: what to do at the scene and in the first days
- 2. The report: how to get your Texas crash report (CR-3)
- 3. The insurance claim: claims phone numbers and first calls
- 4. Treatment: how PIP pays medical bills
- 5. Liens: hospital liens on a settlement
- 6. The demand: what a demand letter does
- 7. The lawsuit: the two-year deadline to sue
Frequently asked questions
Are exemplary damages the same as compensation for medical bills?
No. Medical bills and similar losses are covered by other damages. Section 41.004 says exemplary damages may be awarded only if damages other than nominal damages are awarded.
Does drunk or distracted driving count as gross negligence?
Section 41.001 does not list activities. It asks whether the facts meet its definition of gross negligence, malice or fraud. A court and jury decide that on the evidence. Separately, section 41.008(c) names intoxication assault and intoxication manslaughter among the felonies that affect the dollar limits, covered in the card on section 41.008.
Who has to prove gross negligence?
The claimant. Section 41.003(b) says the burden may not be shifted to the defendant.
Can exemplary damages be awarded against one of several defendants?
Section 41.006 says that when there are two or more defendants, the award must be specific to a defendant, and each is liable only for the amount awarded against that defendant.
Where are the dollar limits on exemplary damages?
They are in a different section, covered in the card on Civil Practice and Remedies Code section 41.008.
Does my own share of fault matter?
Your share of fault affects compensatory recovery under Chapter 33: responsibility greater than 50 percent bars that recovery; otherwise, it is reduced by your percentage. Chapter 33 expressly excludes exemplary-damages claims. However, section 41.004 separately requires an award of damages other than nominal damages before exemplary damages may be awarded.
This page is general information about Texas law and is not legal or medical advice. Every case depends on its own facts. Contact the firm for a free review of yours.
Sources




