Quick answer

Yes. A traffic ticket is a criminal matter, and the injury claim is a civil one decided on its own evidence. Officers often arrive after the crash and decline to cite anyone, but fault is decided by the facts: video, photos, witnesses, vehicle damage, and the traffic laws themselves.

Police officers usually do not see the crash. They arrive afterward, talk to the drivers, and make a judgment in a few minutes, often while one driver is being treated or has already left in an ambulance. Many crashes end with no citation at all, and that is not a finding that nobody was at fault.

The civil standard is different. In an injury claim, fault is decided under negligence rules by a preponderance of the evidence, and under Chapter 33 of the Civil Practice and Remedies Code responsibility can be divided among the drivers. A violation of a traffic statute, such as following too closely or failing to yield, can show negligence whether or not a ticket was written.

The evidence that decides fault is often still out there. The point of impact, the damage pattern, skid marks, dash cam and business video, witness statements, and the vehicles' recorded crash data can establish what happened more reliably than a citation decision.

A ticket does not guarantee a claim either. An insurer still evaluates the injury, the treatment, and the coverage, and a citation that was dismissed or paid without a contest may carry little weight.

If the crash report leaves out witnesses or gets facts wrong, a supplement or correction can sometimes be requested. Owsley Law Firm investigates fault independently and charges no fee unless it wins.

What to do, step by step

  1. Get the crash report and read the narrative and diagram.
  2. Write down your account and collect witness names.
  3. Ask nearby businesses for video right away.
  4. Request a correction or supplement if the report is wrong.
Empty hospital waiting room with rows of chairs

Insurers sometimes point to the lack of a citation as a reason to deny. That is a negotiating position, not a rule, and it often changes when the evidence is presented.

Vehicle data can be decisive. Many cars record speed and braking in the seconds before a crash, and commercial trucks record far more.

Texas proportionate responsibility means the question is often how fault is shared, not whether one driver gets a ticket.

How does a no-ticket claim work step by step? It follows the same path as any Texas crash claim. You report the crash to the other driver’s insurer and your own, get the officer’s crash report, gather the evidence on fault, and document your injuries through consistent medical care. The insurer then accepts, disputes, or splits liability, and you present a demand when the medical picture is clear. If the claim does not resolve, you can file suit before the two-year deadline under Civil Practice and Remedies Code section 16.003, and in court the question of fault is decided on the evidence, not on whether the officer wrote a citation.

Which traffic laws matter even without a ticket? The rules of the road describe what a careful driver does, and they apply whether or not anyone was cited. Transportation Code section 545.062 requires a driver following another vehicle to keep an assured clear distance so they can stop safely without a collision. Transportation Code section 545.060 requires a driver on a marked multilane road to stay as nearly as practical within a single lane and not move out of it unless the move can be made safely. Showing that the other driver broke one of these rules is often the core of a liability argument, with or without a citation.

How do you get and use the crash report? Under Transportation Code section 550.065, a person involved in the collision can obtain the officer’s report on written request and payment of the fee, and the TxDOT online purchase system is the usual route. Read the narrative, the diagram, and any contributing factors the officer recorded. A report can describe what a driver did wrong even when no ticket was issued, and that description can support your account. If the report leaves out a witness or misstates a fact, ask the agency about a supplement promptly, while the officer still remembers the call.

How do insurers handle these claims? An adjuster for the other driver will look for a reason to dispute or divide fault, and the lack of a citation is an easy point to raise. The answer is evidence: photos of the final rest positions, the damage pattern on both vehicles, video from nearby businesses, traffic cameras, or dash cams, witness statements, and data from the vehicles’ event recorders. Under Chapter 33 of the Civil Practice and Remedies Code, the insurer may argue for a percentage split, and each percentage point assigned to you reduces your recovery, so the fault evidence affects value even when liability is not denied outright.

For example, suppose two drivers collide while merging on US 59 near downtown Houston. Each says the other drifted into their lane, the responding officer issues no citation, and the report lists no contributing factor. A business along the frontage road has a camera that faces the highway, and one passenger in a third car stopped to give a name. If the video shows which vehicle left its lane, that evidence can answer the fault question that the report did not. Without it, the case may become a dispute about credibility and damage patterns. This illustration is hypothetical and does not predict how any claim would turn out.

Which edge cases come up most? A ticket that is later dismissed does not mean the driver was not negligent, and a ticket that is paid does not automatically prove the claim. Crashes on private property, like parking lots, may produce no citation at all, but negligence rules still apply. When the other driver claims a sudden medical emergency, or blames a third vehicle that left, the evidence of what happened in the seconds before impact becomes even more important, and an unknown hit-and-run driver brings in your uninsured motorist coverage under its own rules.

Mistakes that cost people money

  • Giving up on a claim because no one was cited.
  • Waiting so long that business video is overwritten.
  • Giving a recorded statement to the other insurer to explain the missing ticket.

Related questions

More on this topic.

Can I get a ticket added later?

Citations are up to the police and prosecutors. The civil claim does not depend on one.

What if I was the one ticketed?

A citation does not decide the civil claim, and fault can still be shared or disputed with evidence.

Does the officer's opinion bind the insurer?

No. Insurers and juries weigh the whole record, including evidence the officer did not have.

Does the police report decide who was at fault in Texas?

No. The report is the officer’s summary, often prepared after the crash with limited information. Insurers and juries weigh it alongside the photos, video, witnesses, and vehicle data.

What if the officer wrote that I caused the crash but did not ticket me?

That notation can hurt, but it is not a final finding. Evidence the officer did not have, like video or an independent witness, can change how an insurer or jury sees the crash, and fault can still be shared.

Can I still recover if both of us were partly at fault?

Yes, if your share of fault is 50 percent or less. Your recovery is reduced by your percentage under Chapter 33 of the Civil Practice and Remedies Code.

How do I get a copy of my Texas crash report?

A person involved in the crash can request the officer’s report on written request and payment of the fee under Transportation Code section 550.065. Most reports are purchased online through the TxDOT crash report system.

Sources

Sources this page relies on

  1. Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code ch. 33
  2. Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 16.003
  3. Tex. Transp. Code § 545.062
  4. Tex. Transp. Code § 545.060
  5. Tex. Transp. Code § 550.065