Quick answer

Yes, as long as your share of fault is 50 percent or less. Texas reduces your recovery by your percentage of fault and bars it only at 51 percent or more.

Texas follows modified comparative fault, called proportionate responsibility, under Chapter 33 of the Civil Practice and Remedies Code. The jury assigns each party a percentage. If you are 20 percent at fault, you recover 80 percent of your damages. If you are 51 percent or more at fault, you recover nothing.

This rule is the reason fault evidence matters even in a clear case. An insurer that cannot deny its driver caused the crash will still try to prove you were speeding, distracted, or could have avoided it, because every percentage point comes off the check.

It is also the reason not to concede anything to an adjuster. Statements like “I didn’t see him” or “I might have been going a little fast” become percentages.

Owsley Law Firm builds the fault case from event data, video, reconstruction, and witnesses so the percentage reflects the physics, not the insurer’s narrative. The consultation is free.

Close-up of a damaged car bumper on a road shoulder

Texas's fault system has features that matter to a partly-at-fault plaintiff. Under section 33.003 the jury assigns a percentage to each claimant, defendant, settling person, and responsible third party, and under section 33.012 the claimant's recovery is reduced by the claimant's own percentage. If a settling person paid something earlier, the court also credits that amount against the judgment.

Responsible third party designation under section 33.004 deserves attention. A defendant can name someone who is not a party to the lawsuit, such as another driver who caused the sudden stop, and ask the jury to assign that person a share of fault; an unidentified driver can be named only if the defendant alleges early in the case that the unknown person committed a criminal act that caused the injury (section 33.004(j)). Any percentage assigned to the third party reduces what the defendant pays, and the plaintiff cannot recover that share from anyone. The rule is one reason evidence identifying every driver matters.

Insurers preview their arguments in the first weeks. They look for speeding, phone use, failure to yield, or failure to wear a seat belt, and they ask leading questions to produce a percentage. Since Nabors Well Services v. Romero (Tex. 2015), evidence that a person was not wearing a seat belt can be admitted to apportion responsibility, so it is best to talk to a lawyer before assuming how it affects your case.

The best response is evidence. Event data recorders, traffic and business camera footage, and independent witnesses replace the insurer's story with facts. A case that looks like an even split from the police report can turn into a small share for the injured driver once the data is examined.

How does a Texas jury actually assign fault percentages? Civil Practice and Remedies Code section 33.003 directs the jury, for each cause of action, to assign a percentage of responsibility to each claimant, each defendant, each settling person, and each designated responsible third party. The percentages are stated in whole numbers and measure each person’s role in causing or contributing to cause the harm, whether by negligence, a defective product, or other conduct that violates a legal standard. The same section bars a jury question about anyone’s conduct without sufficient evidence to support it. Because the numbers are whole, the line under Civil Practice and Remedies Code section 33.001 falls between 50 percent, where you still recover, and 51 percent, where you do not.

How does the math work? For example, suppose a jury finds a driver’s damages are $100,000 and assigns 30 percent of the responsibility to her for changing lanes without checking her mirror and 70 percent to the speeding driver who hit her. Under Civil Practice and Remedies Code section 33.012, the court reduces her damages by her 30 percent, to $70,000. If she had earlier settled with another driver, the court would further reduce the award by the dollar amount of that settlement. If the jury had put her at 51 percent, section 33.001 would bar recovery entirely. The figures are invented arithmetic for illustration only and say nothing about what any case is worth.

How does a responsible third party designation work in practice? A defendant files a motion for leave at least 60 days before trial unless the court finds good cause for a later filing. Under section 33.004, the court must grant leave unless another party objects within 15 days after the motion is served, and an objection succeeds only if the defendant fails, even after a chance to replead, to plead enough facts about the third party’s responsibility. After adequate time for discovery, a party can move to strike the designation for lack of evidence, and the court must grant it unless the defendant raises a genuine fact issue. A designation does not by itself make the third party liable to anyone.

What evidence moves the percentages? The physical facts usually matter more than the first statements. Event data from the vehicles, traffic and business camera video, the damage pattern, and independent witnesses can show speed, braking, and lane position. Two evidence rules are worth knowing. Under Texas Rule of Evidence 410, a plea of nolo contendere (no contest) to a traffic charge is not admissible against the person who made it in a civil case, while a guilty plea is not on that list, so talk to a lawyer before resolving a ticket. Under Texas Rule of Evidence 411, evidence that someone was or was not insured is not admissible to prove negligence. And in Nabors Well Services v. Romero (2015), the Texas Supreme Court held that seat belt nonuse can be admitted to apportion responsibility when the evidence supports it.

Does your share of fault affect family members’ claims? Yes. Chapter 33 defines a claimant to include both the injured person and anyone seeking recovery for that person’s injury or death, such as a spouse with a loss of consortium claim. The injured person’s percentage therefore follows into those related claims. When there are several defendants, each one generally pays only its own percentage of the damages under Civil Practice and Remedies Code section 33.013, unless it is more than 50 percent responsible, in which case it is jointly and severally liable for the full recoverable amount. That rule matters most when one defendant has little insurance.

Which edge cases come up most? Chapter 33 applies to any tort claim in which someone is found responsible for a percentage of the harm, so it governs vehicle damage claims as well as injury claims. Your own first-party benefits, such as PIP and collision, are paid under the policy rather than by fault percentages. An underinsured motorist claim measures what you are legally entitled to recover from the at-fault driver, so the same fault reduction carries into that claim. And when both drivers are hurt and each blames the other, each one’s claim is decided on the same percentages, so a driver found 40 percent at fault can recover 60 percent of their own damages while also owing 40 percent of the other driver’s.

Mistakes that cost people money

  • Apologizing at the scene or saying you should have seen the other car.
  • Assuming that because you share some fault you have no claim.
  • Guessing about your speed or distance in a statement to an insurer.
  • Waiting so long that video and vehicle data are lost.

Related questions

More on this topic.

What if the police report blames me?

A police report is not a legal finding of fault. Officers form impressions at the scene, and the report can be challenged with vehicle data, video, and witnesses. Do not assume a citation or report ends your claim.

What does 51 percent at fault mean for my claim?

If a jury finds you 51 percent or more responsible, Chapter 33 bars any recovery. At 50 percent or less, you recover your damages reduced by your percentage. The line is why small differences in the evidence matter.

Can my own insurance pay if I am partly at fault?

Yes. First-party coverages such as PIP and medical payments usually pay regardless of fault, and collision coverage pays for your car subject to the deductible. Fault affects claims against the other driver, not those benefits.

What happens if both drivers are 50 percent at fault in Texas?

Each driver can still recover, reduced by half. Texas bars recovery only when a claimant’s percentage is greater than 50 percent, and because percentages are stated in whole numbers, 50 percent is the highest share that still allows a recovery.

Should I plead no contest to a traffic ticket after a car accident in Texas?

Ask a lawyer before you decide. Texas Rule of Evidence 410 makes a no contest plea inadmissible against you in a civil case, but a guilty plea is not covered by that rule.

Can the jury blame someone who is not part of the lawsuit?

Yes, if a defendant designates that person as a responsible third party under Civil Practice and Remedies Code section 33.004 and there is evidence of their responsibility. A share assigned to that person reduces what the defendants owe.

Can I still recover if I was speeding when I was hit?

Possibly. Speed is one factor in the fault percentages, and your recovery is reduced by your share as long as it is 50 percent or less. Vehicle data and video often decide how much the speed actually contributed.

Sources

Sources this page relies on

  1. Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code ch. 33
  2. Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 33.003
  3. Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 33.001
  4. Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 33.012
  5. Texas Rules of Evidence (Supreme Court of Texas)
  6. Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 33.013
  7. Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 33.004