Quick answer

Civil Practice and Remedies Code section 18.032 says that in a civil case, proof of the existence of a traffic control device on or alongside a public thoroughfare by a party is prima facie proof of all facts necessary to prove the proper and lawful installation of the device at that place. A control light, stop sign and one-way street sign are included. Any party may rebut the proof.

Official source

Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code, Chapter 18 (Texas Legislature). Read section 18.032 in the Legislature's own text of the chapter.

Section 18.032 of the Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code is titled "Traffic Control Device Presumed to be Lawful." It deals with proof in a civil case. In short, showing that a traffic control device was there is prima facie proof that it was lawfully installed at that place.

This page covers only section 18.032. It says only what the section states about the presumption and when it applies. It does not say who caused a crash, and it does not explain traffic tickets.

What does CPRC 18.032 say?

Short answer

In a civil case, proof that a traffic control device exists on or alongside a public thoroughfare is prima facie proof that it was properly and lawfully installed there. Any party may rebut it.

Subsection (a) reads: "In a civil case, proof of the existence of a traffic control device on or alongside a public thoroughfare by a party is prima facie proof of all facts necessary to prove the proper and lawful installation of the device at that place, including proof of competent authority and an ordinance by a municipality or order by the commissioners court of a county."

The section has four subsections. Subsection (d) says: "Any party may rebut the prima facie proof established under this section."

  • (a): proof of the device is prima facie proof of lawful installation
  • (b): a one-way street sign is prima facie proof of a one-way thoroughfare
  • (c): the devices included
  • (d): any party may rebut the prima facie proof
Hand signing a home insurance policy form on a clipboard

What counts as a traffic control device under this section?

Short answer

Subsection (c) says the term includes a control light, a stop sign and a one-way street sign.

Subsection (c) reads: "In this section, 'traffic control device' includes a control light, stop sign, and one-way street sign."

The word "includes" is in the text. The section does not give a full list of devices.

When does the presumption apply?

Short answer

The section says it applies "in a civil case" when a party proves the device exists on or alongside a public thoroughfare.

The two conditions in subsection (a) are a civil case and proof of the existence of the device on or alongside a public thoroughfare by a party. A personal injury lawsuit after a crash is a civil case.

What the proof covers is stated in the text: "all facts necessary to prove the proper and lawful installation of the device at that place."

What does the one-way street sign rule say?

Short answer

Subsection (b) says proof of the existence of a one-way street sign is prima facie proof that the thoroughfare was designated to be one-way, allowing traffic only in the direction the sign indicates.

Subsection (b) reads: "Proof of the existence of a one-way street sign is prima facie proof that the public thoroughfare on or alongside which the sign is placed was designated by proper and competent authority to be a one-way thoroughfare allowing traffic to go only in the direction indicated by the sign."

Wet two-lane road curving through autumn trees in daylight

Can the presumption be challenged?

Short answer

Yes. Subsection (d) says any party may rebut the prima facie proof established under the section.

The section calls the proof "prima facie" and then says "Any party may rebut the prima facie proof established under this section." The text does not say what evidence is enough to rebut it.

A lawyer can explain how a rebuttal works in a particular case.

How does section 18.032 relate to fault in a crash claim?

Short answer

It deals with proof that a device was lawfully installed. It does not say who caused the crash. Fault is decided under negligence law and, for shared fault, chapter 33.

Chapter 33 says a claimant may not recover damages if the claimant's percentage of responsibility is greater than 50 percent. If the claimant is not barred, section 33.012(a) says the court reduces the damages by a percentage equal to the claimant's percentage of responsibility.

Section 18.032 is a rule about one kind of proof.

Section 18.032 and how each part shows up after a crash

These are the parts of the statute and the kinds of proof that may relate to them. The proof available differs in each crash.
Part of the statuteWhat it saysHow it may be shown after a crash
In a civil case (a)The rule applies in a civil caseA civil injury lawsuit
Proof of the device by a party (a)A party proves a traffic control device exists on or alongside a public thoroughfarePhotos, video and the crash report showing the device and its location
What it proves (a)Prima facie proof of all facts necessary to prove proper and lawful installation at that place, including competent authority and an ordinance or orderProof that the device was in place at that spot. Any party may offer evidence to rebut it
One-way street sign (b)Prima facie proof that the thoroughfare was designated one-way in the direction indicatedPhotos of the sign and the street
Devices included (c)A control light, stop sign and one-way street signPhotos or video of the specific device
Rebuttal (d)Any party may rebut the prima facie proofEvidence offered by a party against lawful installation

How it is proven after a crash

  • Photos and video of the device and where it stands
  • The police crash report and its number
  • Notes of the street name, direction of travel and what the device showed
  • Names and contact information for witnesses

Mistakes that cost people money

  • Assuming section 18.032 decides who caused the crash
  • Assuming the presumption cannot be challenged
  • Assuming the list in subsection (c) is complete
  • Assuming the section applies outside a civil case

Frequently asked questions

What does Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code 18.032 say?

In a civil case, proof of the existence of a traffic control device on or alongside a public thoroughfare by a party is prima facie proof of all facts necessary to prove the proper and lawful installation of the device at that place.

What is a traffic control device under section 18.032?

The term includes a control light, stop sign and one-way street sign.

Can the other side challenge the presumption?

Yes. Subsection (d) says any party may rebut the prima facie proof established under the section.

What does the section say about one-way streets?

Subsection (b) says proof of the existence of a one-way street sign is prima facie proof that the thoroughfare was designated one-way, allowing traffic only in the direction indicated by the sign.

Does section 18.032 say who is at fault in a crash?

No. It concerns proof of lawful installation of a device. Fault is decided under negligence law and, for shared fault, chapter 33.

Does the section apply to every kind of case?

The text says it applies in a civil case.

This page is general information about Texas law and is not legal or medical advice. Every case depends on its own facts. Contact the firm for a free review of yours.

Sources

Sources this page relies on

  1. Texas Legislature, Civil Practice and Remedies Code chapter 18
  2. Texas Legislature, Civil Practice and Remedies Code chapter 33