Quick answer

Transportation Code section 544.004 says the operator of a vehicle or streetcar shall comply with an applicable official traffic-control device placed as provided by the subtitle. Two exceptions are listed: the person is otherwise directed by a traffic officer, police officer or escort flagger, or the person is operating an authorized emergency vehicle and is subject to exceptions under the subtitle. Subsection (b) addresses a device that is not in proper position or not sufficiently legible.

Official source

Texas Transportation Code, Chapter 544 (Texas Legislature). Read section 544.004 in the Legislature's own text of the chapter.

Section 544.004 of the Texas Transportation Code is the general rule about traffic-control devices. It does not say what a particular sign or signal means. Other sections do that.

This page covers only section 544.004. It explains what the text says, how the rule can show up after a crash, and what it means for a civil injury claim. Rules for traffic lights and for stop and yield signs and intersections appear in other sections, including 544.007, 544.010 and 545.153. Section 544.007 has its own page on this site.

What does Texas Transportation Code 544.004 say?

Short answer

It says the operator of a vehicle or streetcar shall comply with an applicable official traffic-control device placed as provided by the subtitle, unless one of two exceptions applies.

Subsection (a) reads: "The operator of a vehicle or streetcar shall comply with an applicable official traffic-control device placed as provided by this subtitle unless the person is" either "otherwise directed by a traffic officer, police officer, or escort flagger" or "operating an authorized emergency vehicle and is subject to exceptions under this subtitle."

The duty covers the operator, meaning the person who drives or has physical control of the vehicle. The rule is about devices that apply to that driver at that place.

  • It applies to the operator of a vehicle or streetcar.
  • It covers an applicable official traffic-control device placed as provided by the subtitle.
  • One exception is direction from a traffic officer, police officer or escort flagger.
  • The other applies when the person is operating an authorized emergency vehicle and is subject to exceptions under the subtitle.
Flatbed tow truck carrying a car on a sunny street

What counts as an official traffic-control device?

Short answer

Section 541.304 defines it as a sign, signal, marking or device that is consistent with the subtitle, placed or erected by a public body or officer having jurisdiction, and used to regulate, warn or guide traffic.

All three parts of the definition apply. The device must be consistent with the subtitle, it must be placed or erected by a public body or officer having jurisdiction, and it must be used to regulate, warn or guide traffic.

Section 544.004 speaks of an "applicable" device. The section does not list which devices are applicable in a given crash.

What if the sign or signal was missing or hard to read?

Short answer

Subsection (b) says a provision requiring an official traffic-control device may not be enforced against an alleged violator if the device is not in proper position and sufficiently legible to an ordinarily observant person at the time and place.

Subsection (b) reads: "A provision of this subtitle requiring an official traffic-control device may not be enforced against an alleged violator if at the time and place of the alleged violation the device is not in proper position and sufficiently legible to an ordinarily observant person." It adds that a provision that does not require an official traffic-control device "is effective regardless of whether a device is in place."

The words of subsection (b) speak of enforcement against an alleged violator. They do not mention civil injury claims.

How is section 544.004 different from sections 544.007 and 545.153?

Short answer

Section 544.004 is the general duty to comply with an applicable device. Sections 544.007 and 545.153 are separate sections. Section 544.007 has its own page on this site.

Section 544.007 is titled traffic-control signals in general. Section 545.153 is titled vehicle entering stop or yield intersection. This page does not restate what they say.

How does section 544.004 affect fault and an injury claim?

Short answer

Section 544.004 does not itself assign fault. Under Civil Practice and Remedies Code chapter 33, the trier of fact determines a percentage of responsibility for each person, including for conduct that violates an applicable legal standard.

Section 33.003(a) says the trier of fact shall determine the percentage of responsibility, stated in whole numbers, for each claimant, each defendant, each settling person and each responsible third party designated under section 33.004. It looks at each person's "causing or contributing to cause in any way the harm," whether by "negligent act or omission" or by "other conduct or activity that violates an applicable legal standard."

Under section 33.001, a claimant may not recover damages if the claimant's percentage of responsibility is greater than 50 percent. If the claimant is not barred, section 33.012(a) says the court shall reduce the damages by a percentage equal to the claimant's percentage of responsibility. The site's page on chapter 33 proportionate responsibility explains these rules.

Bright, empty hospital corridor with white walls

Does a ticket matter in a civil claim under section 544.004?

Short answer

The statute texts read for this page do not say that a ticket, or the lack of one, decides fault in a civil claim.

The text of section 544.004 does not mention a ticket or citation, and neither does the chapter 33 text on percentage of responsibility. Chapter 33 asks about each person's causing or contributing to cause the harm. Section 33.003(b) says that section does not allow a submission to the jury of a question regarding conduct by any person without sufficient evidence to support the submission.

This page does not explain how to handle a ticket.

How can a violation of section 544.004 be proven after a crash?

Short answer

Start with what the device was, where it stood, whether it was in proper position and legible, and what the driver did.

The text sets out several things to look at: whether there was an applicable official traffic-control device, whether it was placed as the subtitle provides, whether it was in proper position and sufficiently legible to an ordinarily observant person, and whether an exception applied, such as direction from an officer or escort flagger.

Photos and video of the device from the approach, the police crash report, and witness statements can speak to those points.

Section 544.004 and how each part shows up after a crash

These are the parts of the statute and the kinds of proof that may relate to them. The proof available differs in each crash.
Part of the statuteWhat it saysHow it may be shown after a crash
Operator of a vehicle or streetcarThe duty is placed on the operatorDriver identity in the police report, vehicle and plate details
Applicable official traffic-control deviceThe device must be official and applicable, placed as provided by the subtitlePhotos or video of the sign, signal or marking, and where it stood
Direction by an officer or escort flaggerAn exception applies if the person is otherwise directed by a traffic officer, police officer or escort flaggerOfficer or flagger statements, the police report, witness statements
Authorized emergency vehicleAn exception applies if the person is operating an authorized emergency vehicle and is subject to exceptions under the subtitleVehicle markings and records, the police report
Device in proper position and legible (subsection (b))A provision requiring a device may not be enforced against an alleged violator if the device is not in proper position and sufficiently legible to an ordinarily observant personPhotos of the device at the time and place, taken from the driver's approach, and witness statements

How it is proven after a crash

  • Photos and video of the sign, signal or marking from the direction the driver approached
  • The police crash report and its number
  • Names and contact details of witnesses
  • Notes on the weather, light and anything blocking the view of the device
  • Dash camera or business video, if any exists

Mistakes that cost people money

  • Assuming that a ticket or the lack of one decides fault
  • Treating section 544.004 as a list of what each sign or signal means
  • Skipping photos of the device because it seems obvious
  • Forgetting that a device that was not in proper position or legible is addressed in subsection (b)

Frequently asked questions

What does Texas Transportation Code 544.004 require?

It says the operator of a vehicle or streetcar shall comply with an applicable official traffic-control device placed as provided by the subtitle, unless the person is otherwise directed by a traffic officer, police officer or escort flagger, or is operating an authorized emergency vehicle and is subject to exceptions under the subtitle.

What is an official traffic-control device in Texas?

Section 541.304 defines it as a sign, signal, marking or device that is consistent with the subtitle, placed or erected by a public body or officer having jurisdiction, and used to regulate, warn or guide traffic.

Does section 544.004 apply if a sign was missing or not legible?

Subsection (b) says a provision requiring an official traffic-control device may not be enforced against an alleged violator if the device is not in proper position and sufficiently legible to an ordinarily observant person at the time and place.

Does a ticket decide fault in a civil claim?

The statute texts read for this page do not say so. Fault is decided under negligence law and Civil Practice and Remedies Code chapter 33.

What happens if the injured person is partly at fault?

Under chapter 33, a claimant may not recover if the claimant's percentage of responsibility is greater than 50 percent. Otherwise the court reduces the damages by that percentage.

Where are the rules for traffic lights and stop or yield intersections?

In several sections, including 544.007, 544.010 and 545.153. Section 544.007 has its own page on this site.

This page is general information about Texas law and is not legal or medical advice. Every case depends on its own facts. Contact the firm for a free review of yours.

Sources

Sources this page relies on

  1. Texas Legislature, Transportation Code chapter 544
  2. Texas Legislature, Civil Practice and Remedies Code chapter 33
  3. Texas Legislature, Transportation Code chapter 541 (definitions)