Quick answer

The crash report, photographs, medical records from the first visit forward, witness contacts, and the insurance information for every vehicle. For serious cases, vehicle event data, camera footage, and phone records, which must be preserved quickly.

Fault evidence: the CR-3 crash report, photographs of vehicles and the scene, camera footage from businesses and traffic cameras, witness statements, event data recorders, and, in distraction cases, phone records obtained by subpoena.

Injury evidence: every medical record from the day of the crash forward, imaging, treating physician opinions on causation and future care, and employer records for lost wages.

Insurance evidence: the at-fault driver’s policy, any employer or vehicle-owner policy, and your own declarations page for PIP and UM/UIM.

Timing is the hard part. Camera footage is overwritten in days, and trucking companies keep electronic logs for six months. Owsley Law Firm sends preservation letters the week a client calls.

What to do, step by step

  1. Photograph the vehicles, plates, road, signals, debris, and injuries, and record the date, time, and weather.
  2. Get the crash report number and, when available, the report itself.
  3. Collect witness names and phone numbers and ask them to write a short account.
  4. See a doctor promptly, and keep every record, bill, and receipt in one place.
  5. Keep a short journal of symptoms, missed work, and how injuries affect daily life.
  6. Ask a lawyer to send preservation letters for video, vehicle data, and company records.
A hand signing insurance paperwork at a desk

The types of evidence carry different weight. Physical evidence, such as vehicle damage, skid marks, and event data, is hard to argue with. Documents, such as medical records and employer wage records, are treated as reliable when they are made close to the events. Testimony, from the parties and witnesses, is important but is easily attacked for bias or poor memory.

Vehicle data deserves special mention. Most modern vehicles record speed, braking, and throttle in the moments before an impact, and commercial trucks record much more. Downloading it requires the vehicle to be preserved and the right equipment, which is why vehicles should not be repaired or salvaged until a lawyer has had a chance to send a preservation demand.

Medical evidence has to connect the injury to the crash. Records made at the first visit describing the mechanism of injury and symptoms are important, and treating physicians' opinions on causation and future care carry weight. Gaps in treatment give the insurer an argument, so follow the treatment plan, and explain any gap with a real reason.

Texas allows paid or incurred medical expenses to be recovered under Civil Practice and Remedies Code section 41.0105, and lost earnings are computed after taxes under section 18.091, so records showing what was actually paid and what was actually earned are the foundation of the economic damages. Pay stubs, tax returns, and employer letters should be gathered early.

What makes evidence usable, not just available? It has to be admissible. Texas Rule of Evidence 901 requires evidence sufficient to support a finding that an item is what it is claimed to be, and testimony from a witness with knowledge is one recognized way to do that. For a photograph or video, that usually means the person who took it, or someone who saw the scene, can testify that it shows what it is offered to show. Keeping the original files, with their date and time data, makes that testimony easier.

How do medical bills, phone records, and wage records get into evidence? Most are business records. Texas Rule of Evidence 803(6) allows records made at or near the time by someone with knowledge, kept in the regular course of business, when making the record was a regular practice. Under Rule 902(10), those records can be proved by a custodian’s affidavit or unsworn declaration served on every other party at least 14 days before trial, instead of calling a records witness. Separately, Civil Practice and Remedies Code section 18.001 lets an affidavit support a finding that medical charges were reasonable and services necessary unless it is properly controverted.

Why does what I tell my doctor matter so much? Texas Rule of Evidence 803(4) allows statements made for, and reasonably pertinent to, medical diagnosis or treatment that describe medical history, symptoms, their inception, or their general cause. A clear account at the first visit of how the crash happened and when each symptom started becomes part of the record the claim relies on. The other driver’s own words matter too: under Rule 801(e)(2), a party’s own statement offered against that party is not hearsay, so an apology or admission at the scene can be used.

How is evidence gathered from people who are not part of the case? Before suit, the main tool is a preservation letter to anyone holding video, data, or records. Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 202 also allows a petition for a deposition to investigate a potential claim, which the court grants only if it finds the procedure may prevent a failure or delay of justice or that its likely benefit outweighs the burden. After suit is filed, Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 205 lets a party compel documents from a nonparty, such as a business with a camera or a phone carrier, by serving notice on everyone and a subpoena. Electronic data must be specifically requested under Rule 196.4.

How do insurers test the evidence? Adjusters look for gaps between the crash and the first medical visit, gaps in treatment, prior injuries to the same body part, low visible vehicle damage, and social media posts that seem inconsistent with the claimed injuries. Each of those is answered with more evidence, not less: an explanation in the medical records, repair estimates and photographs of hidden damage, prior records that show a change, and an honest account of what the posts show. In a lawsuit, the defense may also seek an examination under Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 204.1.

For example, suppose a driver turning left at an intersection in southwest Houston hits an oncoming car, and each driver says the light was green for them. There are no independent witnesses at the scene. The injured driver photographs both cars and the intersection, notes a gas station camera facing the corner, and asks a lawyer to send a preservation letter that week. The station’s footage, the crash report, and both vehicles’ event data then become the evidence on who had the light. This illustration is hypothetical and is not a prediction of any result.

Which edge cases come up most? Your own words can be used against you just as the other driver’s can, because Rule 801(e)(2) applies to any party, so posts, texts, and recorded statements deserve care. Deleting posts after a claim begins can create a spoliation problem under Brookshire Bros. v. Aldridge (Tex. 2014). And the two-year limit under Civil Practice and Remedies Code section 16.003 keeps running while evidence is collected, so evidence gathering should run alongside the deadline, not in place of watching it.

Mistakes that cost people money

  • Relying on memory instead of photos and notes taken close to the crash.
  • Repairing or disposing of the vehicle before its data is downloaded.
  • Deleting social media posts after a claim begins, which can look like concealment.
  • Letting treatment lapse and then trying to explain the gap later.

Related questions

More on this topic.

Are photos from my phone good enough?

Yes, phone photos are commonly used. Keep the originals with their date and time data, take more than you think you need, and back them up so they are not lost with the phone.

Can a lawyer get camera footage after several weeks?

Sometimes, but many systems overwrite within days or weeks. A prompt preservation request improves the chance, and a delay can make footage unavailable, so contact a lawyer as early as possible.

What if I have no witnesses?

Physical evidence, vehicle data, camera footage, and the crash report can establish what happened without witnesses. A lawyer can also canvass the area for cameras and people who saw the crash but did not stop.

Can I use dashcam video as evidence in a Texas car accident claim?

Yes, if it is authenticated. Under Texas Rule of Evidence 901, someone must be able to show the video is what it claims to be, often the owner of the camera or a person who saw the scene. Keep the original file and do not edit it.

Can my social media be used against me after a car accident?

Yes. Under Texas Rule of Evidence 801(e)(2), a party’s own statements offered against that party are not hearsay, and that includes posts and messages. Do not delete anything after a claim begins, but think carefully before posting.

What is a preservation letter after a car accident?

It is a written demand asking a person or company to keep specific evidence, such as video, vehicle data, phone records, or driver files. Under Brookshire Bros. v. Aldridge (Tex. 2014), a duty to preserve arises when a party knows or reasonably should know there is a substantial chance of a claim, and a letter helps establish that knowledge.

How do I get medical records for my car accident claim?

Request them from each provider, including billing records, and ask for a records affidavit. Texas Rule of Evidence 902(10) lets business records be proved with a custodian’s affidavit served at least 14 days before trial, and Civil Practice and Remedies Code section 18.001 lets an affidavit address whether the charges were reasonable and the care necessary.

Sources

Sources this page relies on

  1. Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 41.0105
  2. Texas Rules of Evidence (Supreme Court of Texas)
  3. Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 18.001
  4. Texas Rules of Civil Procedure (Supreme Court of Texas)
  5. Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 16.003