Quick answer

Yes. Public posts can be found and used to argue your injuries are not serious, and in a lawsuit relevant posts can be requested in discovery. Do not post about the crash or your activities, and do not delete anything, because destroying evidence can be sanctioned.

Insurance adjusters and defense lawyers check social media. A photo at a party, a vacation check-in, or a post saying you are feeling better can be used to argue that your pain is exaggerated, even if the photo was taken on a good day or before the crash.

In a lawsuit, the reach is wider. Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 192.3 allows discovery of any matter that is not privileged and is relevant to the case. Posts, photos, and messages that bear on your injuries or activities can be requested, and private settings do not automatically protect them.

Do not delete posts. Once a claim is likely, a party has a duty to preserve relevant evidence. The Texas Supreme Court set out the framework for spoliation, the destruction of evidence, in Brookshire Bros. v. Aldridge (2014), and a court can respond with remedies that include a jury instruction against the party who destroyed it.

The safest course is to stop posting about the crash, your injuries, your treatment, and your physical activities until the case is over. Ask friends and family not to tag you or post about the crash. Do not accept new friend or follow requests from people you do not know.

Video posts are especially risky. A short clip of you lifting a child, dancing at a wedding, or carrying groceries can be played for a jury without the context of the pain afterward or the days you could not get out of bed. Even if the activity was harmless, it becomes an argument you have to answer.

Online reviews and comments are covered too. Posting about the other driver, the insurer, or the crash itself can create statements you will be asked about later. If you need to vent, talk to your lawyer instead.

Remember that recovery is real progress, not a weakness in your case. The goal is not to hide that you are getting better, but to make sure the record of your recovery comes from your doctors rather than from snapshots online.

If you have already posted something, tell your lawyer rather than deleting it. Owsley Law Firm reviews these issues with clients at the start of every case and charges no fee unless it wins.

What to do, step by step

  1. Set your accounts to private.
  2. Stop posting about the crash, your injuries, or physical activities.
  3. Do not delete anything; tell your lawyer about posts that concern you.
  4. Ask family and friends not to tag you or post about the crash.
Close-up of a damaged car bumper on a road shoulder

Dating apps and professional networking profiles are included. A profile that lists hobbies like running or weightlifting, or a job update about returning to full duty, can be cited by the defense. Review your profiles with your lawyer and leave them alone rather than editing them after the crash.

Fitness trackers, ride-sharing receipts, and location data can raise the same issues as posts. Anything that shows your activity level or where you were may be requested if it is relevant to your injuries. Keep using them normally, but do not delete data or accounts while the claim is open.

A lawyer can sometimes use social media too. Posts by the other driver, witnesses, or a commercial company can be evidence of what happened, such as a driver posting from the road. Those posts should be captured early before they are taken down.

Context is often lost online. A smiling photo at a child’s birthday says nothing about the pain afterward, but an adjuster may present it that way. Not posting avoids the argument entirely.

Messages can be discoverable too. Private messages about the crash or your recovery may be relevant, so treat them with the same care as public posts.

How does a request for social media arrive in a Texas lawsuit? Usually as written discovery. The defense may serve an interrogatory asking you to list your accounts and a request for production asking for posts, photos, or messages about the crash, your injuries, or your activities. Under Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 196, the response is generally due 30 days after service, and electronic data must be specifically requested with the form of production stated. Your lawyer can object to requests that are not limited to relevant matters, and disputes over scope that the lawyers cannot resolve go to the judge.

Why does the defense ask you instead of the platform? A federal law, the Stored Communications Act, generally prohibits a provider of an electronic communication service to the public from knowingly divulging the contents of stored communications, under 18 U.S.C. section 2702. The statute lists exceptions, including disclosure with the lawful consent of the person who sent the communication or the subscriber. That is one reason requests for your content are usually directed to you, or come with a request that you sign an authorization, rather than going straight to the company. Never sign an authorization for account access without your lawyer reviewing it.

How can a post be used at trial? Under Texas Rule of Evidence 801, a statement offered against a party that the party made is not hearsay. Your own posts, captions, comments, and messages can therefore be offered by the defense as your statements, and a caption like back to normal can carry more weight with a jury than the photo itself. Posts by friends and relatives are different because they are not your statements, but they can still be requested or subpoenaed if they are relevant, and they can lead to questions in your deposition.

Can your own posts help you? Sometimes, but only if they are handled the right way. Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 193 says a party who fails to timely disclose material in discovery may not introduce it at trial unless the court finds good cause or no unfair surprise or prejudice. If you want to use a post that shows the hospital stay or a canceled trip, it has to be produced in discovery like any other evidence. Selective production, sharing helpful posts and withholding harmful ones, is exactly what the discovery rules are designed to prevent.

For example, suppose a woman injures her lower back in a crash on the Katy Freeway. Three weeks later, her sister posts a photo of her smiling and holding a birthday cake at a family party, and she comments on it. Months into the lawsuit, the defense requests all photos and posts showing her physical activities since the crash. Her lawyer produces the relevant posts, including the photo, and prepares her and her sister to explain that she sat for most of the party and spent the next day in bed, consistent with her medical records. The photo becomes something to explain rather than something that was hidden. This illustration is hypothetical and does not predict any result.

What about deactivating, editing, or using posts from the other side? Deactivating an account, changing old captions, or removing tags can look like an effort to hide evidence once a claim is likely, so ask your lawyer before changing anything. The Texas Supreme Court’s spoliation framework in Brookshire Bros. v. Aldridge (2014) lets a court respond to destroyed evidence, and Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 215 allows sanctions for discovery failures. The same principles help you when the other driver posted from the road or a trucking company’s driver bragged about the trip: those posts should be captured with dates and links early, because the platform generally will not hand over their content without the account holder’s consent.

Related questions

More on this topic.

Are private accounts safe?

Private settings reduce what an adjuster can see, but they do not prevent discovery of relevant content in a lawsuit.

Can I post after the case ends?

Yes. Once the case is resolved, the concern ends.

What if someone else posted a photo of me?

Tell your lawyer. Do not ask the person to delete it without advice.

Can an insurance company subpoena my Facebook or Instagram account?

A federal law, 18 U.S.C. section 2702, generally bars platforms from disclosing the contents of your communications, with exceptions such as your consent. In a lawsuit, the defense usually requests relevant content from you through discovery instead.

Should I deactivate my social media after a car accident?

Ask your lawyer first. Deactivating, deleting, or editing can look like hiding evidence once a claim is likely. The safer course is usually to stop posting and leave existing content alone.

Can my posts be used against me in court in Texas?

Yes. Under Texas Rule of Evidence 801, your own statement offered against you by the other side is not hearsay, so posts, captions, and messages you wrote can be offered as evidence if they are relevant.

Can I use my own social media posts to help my injury case?

Possibly, but they must be disclosed in discovery like any other evidence. Under Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 193, material not timely disclosed may be excluded at trial.

Sources

Sources this page relies on

  1. Texas Rules of Civil Procedure (Supreme Court of Texas)
  2. Texas Rules of Evidence (Supreme Court of Texas)