Quick answer

Discovery is the stage after a lawsuit is filed when each side must share information: initial disclosures within 30 days after the first answer, written questions, document requests, and depositions. It is how the full record of the crash, the injuries, and the insurance comes out.

Discovery is governed by the Texas Rules of Civil Procedure. Under Rule 194.2, each party must make initial disclosures within 30 days after the first answer is filed unless the parties agree or the court orders otherwise. Those disclosures include the people with knowledge of the facts, the insurance policies, and the damages being claimed.

The scope is broad. Rule 192.3 allows discovery of any matter that is not privileged and is relevant to the case. In a crash case that means the crash report, photographs, phone records when distraction is an issue, vehicle data, medical records, employment records for lost wages, and the defense insurer’s policies.

Written discovery comes first: interrogatories that must be answered under oath, requests for production of documents, and requests for admission. Then come depositions, recorded testimony taken under oath. Rule 199.5 limits each side to six hours of examination of any one witness.

Smaller cases can move faster. Under Rule 169, a suit seeking $325,000 or less in monetary relief, excluding interest and some other items, can proceed as an expedited action with limited discovery and an earlier trial setting. Larger cases follow a discovery control plan under Rule 190.

Discovery also reveals the defense’s theory of the case. Their interrogatory answers, expert designations, and the questions in your deposition show whether they plan to dispute fault, argue that your injuries came from something else, or challenge the cost of your treatment. Knowing that early helps your lawyer prepare the evidence to answer it.

Requests for admission are a useful tool. They ask the other side to admit or deny specific facts, such as that their driver ran a red light. Facts admitted do not have to be proven at trial, which can narrow the dispute.

Discovery takes time and is where cases are won or lost. Owsley Law Firm prepares clients for every step, answers discovery on schedule, and charges no fee unless it wins.

What to do, step by step

  1. Initial disclosures: both sides exchange basic information within 30 days after the first answer.
  2. Written discovery: interrogatories, requests for production, and requests for admission.
  3. Records: medical, employment, phone, and vehicle data are obtained.
  4. Depositions: the parties, witnesses, and experts testify under oath.
  5. Expert reports: medical and reconstruction experts are designated.
Close-up of a damaged car bumper on a road shoulder

Third parties can be part of discovery too. Hospitals, employers, phone carriers, and businesses with security video can be served with subpoenas or deposition notices for records. That is often how the most objective evidence in a car case, such as video of the crash or the other driver’s phone activity, is obtained.

Expedited actions have tighter limits. When a case proceeds under Rule 169, discovery is governed by Rule 190.2, and the court must set an earlier trial date on request. The tradeoff is that the recovery is capped at $325,000, excluding interest, statutory or punitive damages, and attorney fees and costs, so that path only makes sense for some claims.

Medical discovery is often the largest part of a car case. The defense will request records from every provider who treated you, sometimes for years before the crash, to look for preexisting conditions. Your lawyer can limit requests to what is relevant and prepare you to explain your medical history accurately.

Discovery can be contested. When a party refuses to produce something, the other side can ask the court to compel it. Courts can also limit discovery that is overly broad or burdensome.

Your role is to answer accurately and on time. Your lawyer prepares the written answers with you and reviews documents before they are produced, so nothing is shared that should not be.

How fast does each side have to respond to written discovery? Under the Texas Rules of Civil Procedure, the responding party generally must serve written answers within 30 days after it is served with interrogatories (Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 197), requests for production (Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 196), or requests for admission (Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 198). Interrogatory answers must be signed under oath, with limited exceptions. A response may include objections and assertions of privilege, but those must follow the rules, and the parties can agree to extend deadlines or ask the court to change them.

What happens if a request for admission is not answered? Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 198 is unforgiving. If a response is not served on time, the request is considered admitted without the need for a court order. A matter admitted is conclusively established for that case unless the court allows it to be withdrawn, which requires good cause and a finding that the other side will not be unduly prejudiced. Admissions can be used only in the pending case, not in any other proceeding. Missing a response deadline is one of the few discovery mistakes that can decide a fact on its own.

How much discovery is allowed? It depends on the discovery level. In a case governed by a Level 2 plan under Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 190, each party may serve no more than 25 written interrogatories on any other party, not counting those that only ask a party to identify or authenticate documents, and each discrete subpart counts as a separate interrogatory. Each side has no more than 50 hours of oral depositions with the opposing parties, their experts, and people they control, and the discovery period ends on the earlier of 30 days before trial or nine months after the first initial disclosures are due. Expedited cases under Rule 169 have tighter Level 1 limits, and complex cases can get a Level 3 plan by court order.

When are experts named? Unless the court orders a different schedule, Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 195 requires a party seeking affirmative relief, which is usually the injured person, to designate its testifying experts 90 days before the end of the discovery period, and all other parties to designate theirs 60 days before. In a car crash case, those experts may include treating doctors, a medical expert on causation, an accident reconstructionist, or an economist. Because the injured person goes first, the medical records and opinions need to be organized well before that deadline.

For example, suppose a driver is rear-ended on Interstate 10 and sues the other driver, who says traffic stopped suddenly. The injured driver’s lawyer serves a request for admission asking the defendant to admit he was using his phone, a request for production of the phone records, and a specific request for electronic data under Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 196 that names the form of production. The defense serves interrogatories asking about prior injuries and a request for medical records going back several years. Each side has 30 days to respond, objections to overbroad requests get resolved by agreement or by the court, and the answers shape what each side’s experts address. This illustration is hypothetical and does not predict any result.

What if a party hides or forgets something? Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 193 says a party who fails to timely make, amend, or supplement a discovery response may not introduce the material that was not disclosed, or call a witness other than a named party who was not timely identified, unless the court finds good cause or no unfair surprise or prejudice. The court can also postpone trial to allow the response and further discovery. For more serious failures, Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 215 lets the court order sanctions that include charging expenses, treating facts as established, barring evidence, striking pleadings, or dismissal. The same rules protect the injured person when the defense is the side withholding information.

Related questions

More on this topic.

How long does discovery take?

It depends on the court’s schedule and the case’s complexity. Expedited actions move faster; complex cases take longer.

Will the defense see all my medical records?

Relevant records, yes. Your lawyer can object to requests that reach unrelated or privileged information.

Do I have to answer questions under oath?

Yes, written interrogatories and deposition testimony are under oath.

How long do I have to answer interrogatories in Texas?

Generally 30 days after they are served, under Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 197. The answers must be signed under oath, and your lawyer prepares them with you and can raise objections to improper questions.

What happens if the other driver does not respond to discovery?

Unanswered requests for admission are deemed admitted under Rule 198. For other failures, your lawyer can ask the court to compel answers and seek sanctions under Rule 215, and undisclosed evidence may be excluded under Rule 193.

Can I refuse to answer some discovery questions?

A response may include objections and assertions of privilege as the rules require, for example to requests that reach unrelated medical history or privileged communications with your lawyer. Disputes the lawyers cannot resolve go to the judge.

Is discovery different if my case is in federal court?

Yes. Federal cases follow the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, under which initial disclosures are generally due within 14 days after the parties’ Rule 26(f) conference, and the federal judge’s scheduling order sets the deadlines.

Sources

Sources this page relies on

  1. Texas Rules of Civil Procedure (Supreme Court of Texas)