Quick answer

Driver error. In NHTSA's national crash causation study, the critical reason for the crash was assigned to the driver in an estimated 94 percent of crashes, most often recognition errors like distraction and inattention, followed by decision errors like speeding or misjudging a gap.

The best-known figure comes from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration's National Motor Vehicle Crash Causation Survey. In its 2015 summary, NHTSA reported that the critical reason, the last event in the chain leading to the crash, was assigned to the driver in an estimated 94 percent of crashes, to the vehicle in about 2 percent, and to the environment, such as slick roads or weather, in about 2 percent.

NHTSA broke the driver errors down. Recognition errors, including inattention, distraction, and inadequate surveillance, were assigned in about 41 percent of crashes. Decision errors, like driving too fast for conditions, illegal maneuvers, and misjudging another vehicle's speed or a gap, were about 33 percent. Performance errors, such as overcompensation or poor directional control, were about 11 percent, and non-performance errors, mostly falling asleep, about 7 percent.

NHTSA was careful about what the number means: assigning the critical reason to a driver was not intended to blame that driver for causing the crash. In a Texas injury claim, fault is a legal question decided by the evidence, and under Chapter 33 of the Civil Practice and Remedies Code it can be divided among several drivers or companies.

The categories still match what Texas injury cases are built on: phone use and texting while driving, following too closely, failing to yield on a left turn, speeding, unsafe lane changes, and fatigue in commercial trucking. Each points to evidence worth getting early, such as phone records, vehicle data, video, and hours-of-service logs.

If another driver's error caused your crash, Owsley Law Firm can investigate what happened and pursue the claim, with no fee unless it wins.

What to do, step by step

  1. Note what the other driver was doing just before the crash.
  2. Ask witnesses what they saw, especially about phone use or speed.
  3. Look for nearby cameras on businesses, homes, and intersections.
  4. Get the crash report and check the contributing factors listed.
Traffic light at a rainy Houston intersection

The officer's crash report lists contributing factors, such as failure to control speed, driver inattention, or failure to yield. Those entries are not the final word on fault, but they often frame the insurer's first view of the claim.

Electronic evidence increasingly decides cause: phone records for distraction, event data recorders for speed and braking, and in truck cases, electronic logging devices for fatigue.

What do Texas crash numbers show? TxDOT’s Crash Facts report for 2025 counted 3,769 people killed in Texas traffic crashes, with 1,201 deaths in run-off-the-road crashes and 955 in intersection crashes. The same report counted 906 people killed in crashes involving an alcohol-impaired driver, about 24 percent of all deaths, and 308 deaths in crashes involving distracted driving. Distraction counts depend on what investigators can document after the fact, so they are best read as a floor rather than a complete count.

How do the common causes match Texas traffic law? Following too closely violates Transportation Code section 545.062, which requires an assured clear distance so the driver can stop safely without hitting the vehicle ahead. A left turn across oncoming traffic is governed by Transportation Code section 545.152, which requires the turning driver to yield to oncoming vehicles that are close enough to be an immediate hazard. Speeding includes driving faster than is reasonable and prudent for conditions under section 545.351, even below the posted limit. Unsafe lane changes run against section 545.060, and reading or sending a text while driving is an offense under section 545.4251 unless the vehicle is stopped.

What evidence proves the cause in a real claim? It depends on the cause. A rear-end crash often turns on the following distance and whether the front car stopped suddenly, so brake light video and vehicle data help. A left-turn crash turns on the light cycle, sight lines, and the speed of the oncoming car. Distraction is proved through phone records, in-car video, and admissions. Fatigue in truck crashes is proved through hours-of-service logs under 49 CFR Part 395. Impairment is proved through blood or breath results, receipts, and witness accounts. Each type of evidence has a short life, so it should be requested early.

How do insurers use cause to decide fault? The adjuster reads the crash report’s contributing factors, takes recorded statements, and looks at photos of the damage. Damage location tells a lot: front damage on one car and rear damage on the other suggests a following-distance problem, while side damage at an intersection points to a right-of-way question. Under Chapter 33 of the Civil Practice and Remedies Code, insurers often argue that both drivers share some fault, such as an oncoming driver who was speeding when a car turned left in front of it, because any percentage assigned to you reduces what they pay.

For example, suppose a driver stopped in traffic on a Houston freeway is struck from behind by a pickup. The pickup driver says the front car “slammed on the brakes.” The officer lists failure to control speed as a contributing factor. Under section 545.062, the following driver was required to keep enough distance to stop safely, so the sudden-stop explanation usually does not shift much fault on its own, but the insurer may still raise it. A dash cam, the pickup’s phone records, or a witness can settle the question. This example illustrates how cause and evidence connect; it does not predict a result.

What about crashes with more than one cause? Many crashes combine factors: a distracted driver who was also speeding, a truck driver near the end of a long shift on a poorly lit road, or a drunk driver who ran a red light. A vehicle defect or a missing traffic sign can also contribute. When several parties contributed, Texas law lets a jury assign a percentage of responsibility to each, which is why identifying every cause, and every responsible party, matters to the claim.

Mistakes that cost people money

  • Assuming the crash report's contributing factors cannot be corrected.
  • Waiting until video from nearby cameras is overwritten.
  • Overlooking a vehicle defect or road hazard as a contributing cause.

Related questions

More on this topic.

Is distracted driving the top cause?

Recognition errors, which include distraction and inattention, were the most common category in NHTSA's crash causation study.

Can more than one driver be at fault?

Yes. Texas juries can divide fault among several drivers and companies.

Do road conditions cause many crashes?

NHTSA assigned the critical reason to the environment, such as weather or slick roads, in about 2 percent of crashes studied.

What is the number one cause of car accidents in Texas?

There is no single official ranking that settles it, but driver behavior dominates. TxDOT’s 2025 Crash Facts report counted 906 deaths in crashes involving an alcohol-impaired driver, about 24 percent of traffic deaths, and national research assigns the critical reason for most crashes to driver error.

Who is at fault in a rear-end collision in Texas?

Usually the following driver, because Transportation Code section 545.062 requires enough distance to stop safely. Fault can be shared if the front driver did something unexpected, like cutting in and braking, and the evidence decides the split.

Who is at fault in a left-turn accident in Texas?

Usually the turning driver, who must yield to oncoming traffic that is close enough to be an immediate hazard under Transportation Code section 545.152. The oncoming driver may share fault if speeding or running a red light.

Is texting and driving illegal in Texas?

Yes. Transportation Code section 545.4251 makes it an offense to read, write, or send an electronic message on a portable device while operating a vehicle unless the vehicle is stopped.

Sources

Sources this page relies on

  1. Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code ch. 33
  2. Tex. Transp. Code § 545.4251
  3. Tex. Transp. Code § 545.062
  4. Tex. Transp. Code § 545.152
  5. 49 C.F.R. Part 395 (hours of service)