Yes. Not wearing a seat belt does not bar your claim in Texas. Since Nabors Well Services v. Romero in 2015, the defense can offer evidence that you were unbelted, but only to argue that your share of responsibility for your injuries should be increased, and only with evidence tying the missing belt to the injuries.
Transportation Code section 545.413 requires anyone 15 or older riding in a seat with a safety belt to wear it, and makes the driver responsible for securing passengers younger than 17 who are not in a child safety seat. Breaking that rule is a traffic offense. It does not take away the right to recover from the driver who caused the crash.
For years Texas excluded seat belt evidence from injury trials entirely. In Nabors Well Services v. Romero, 456 S.W.3d 553 (Tex. 2015), the Texas Supreme Court changed that. Evidence that an injured person was not wearing a seat belt is now admissible to apportion responsibility under Chapter 33 of the Civil Practice and Remedies Code, if it is relevant to the injuries.
Relevance is the key limitation. The defense must connect the missing belt to the injuries, usually with an expert in biomechanics or accident reconstruction. A belt helps in some crashes and not others. It may not change a leg crushed by intrusion into the footwell, or an injury from a side impact, the same way it changes ejection or a head striking the windshield.
The effect is a percentage, not a bar. If a jury finds you partly responsible for your own injuries, your recovery is reduced by that share. You are barred only if your total share exceeds 50 percent, which seat belt evidence alone rarely produces when the other driver caused the crash.
Insurers bring up the seat belt early, often in the first phone call, to set expectations low. The answer to that tactic is not to argue on the phone but to let the evidence speak: the crash report, the vehicle damage, the airbag deployment data, and the injuries themselves. An adjuster who sees a well-documented claim is less likely to rely on an unproven seat belt discount.
Insurers raise the seat belt question early to discount offers. Owsley Law Firm answers it with the vehicle evidence and medical records, and charges no fee unless it wins.
What to do, step by step
- Get medical care and tell providers how the crash happened.
- Keep the vehicle until the restraints can be inspected.
- Photograph the interior, airbags, and belts.
- Do not discuss belt use with the other driver’s insurer.
- Talk to a lawyer about how the crash type affects the argument.

The seat belt argument often depends on the type of crash. In a frontal impact, an unbelted occupant may strike the steering wheel or windshield. In a side impact or a crash with heavy intrusion, a belt may make little difference to the injuries that matter. The defense has to prove the difference, not assume it.
Children are treated separately. The driver is responsible for securing passengers younger than 17, and the law places the duty to buckle a child on the driver.
Medical evidence often answers the seat belt argument. Treating physicians and biomechanical experts can explain which injuries a belt would have prevented and which it would not have changed. Many crash injuries, including those from intrusion into the cabin or from a side impact, occur whether or not the occupant was belted.
How does the seat belt defense actually work in a Texas case? The Texas Supreme Court set out the procedure in Nabors Well Services v. Romero. Seat belt evidence is admissible only if it is relevant, and the defendant can establish relevance only with evidence that not wearing a belt caused or contributed to cause the plaintiff’s injuries. The trial judge should first consider that evidence outside the jury’s presence, so jurors do not hear about belt use before the judge decides it is relevant. Even relevant evidence can still be excluded under Texas Rule of Evidence 403.
Does the defense always need an expert? Usually, but not always. The court said expert testimony will often be required to establish relevance, and declined to say it is required in every case. If the evidence comes in, the jury does not answer a separate seat belt question. Romero held that one apportionment of responsibility should cover both the conduct that caused the crash and any conduct that made the injuries worse, and it overruled the 1974 decision in Carnation Co. v. Wong that had kept seat belt evidence out.
How is a seat belt argument different from a failure to mitigate argument? Romero kept the two apart. Not wearing a belt happens before the crash, so it goes into the percentage of responsibility. Conduct after the crash, such as not following medical advice, is handled differently: it reduces the damages award and is not part of the responsibility percentage. Keeping those two ideas separate matters when an insurer tries to stack them to justify a lower offer.
How do insurers build the seat belt argument? They start with the crash report, which on the current Texas form records the restraint used by each person, and with the vehicle data. Under 49 CFR Part 563, light vehicles built on or after September 1, 2012 that have an event data recorder must capture the driver’s belt status in a qualifying crash. A claim where the medical records show injuries from intrusion or a side impact gives the adjuster less room to argue the belt mattered, while ejection or a head striking the windshield invites the argument. A recorded admission that you were unbelted, given before anyone has studied how the injuries happened, can be used to push for a discount even when no one has connected the two.
For example, suppose an unbelted passenger in a pickup is hurt when another driver runs a stop sign and hits the truck broadside on the passenger side, and the door pushing inward fractures her pelvis. The other driver’s insurer raises the missing belt. Under Romero, it would need evidence that wearing the belt would have prevented or reduced that particular injury, and the judge would decide outside the jury’s presence whether that evidence is relevant. Whether a jury would assign her any percentage depends on that evidence. This illustration is hypothetical and does not predict any result.
Which situations are different? Transportation Code section 545.413(e) gives a defense to the traffic offense for a person with a written statement from a licensed physician that they should not wear a belt for a medical reason, and for certain workers who must get in and out of a vehicle often, such as postal carriers servicing mailboxes. Those defenses apply to the ticket. In a civil case, Romero said that when an unbelted person was not personally violating a seat belt law, the jury may consider whether they acted with reasonable care. For children, the jury may apportion responsibility to the person the law makes responsible for restraining the child, and a minor is held only to the care of an ordinarily prudent child of the same age, intelligence, experience, and capacity. Under section 545.412, a child younger than eight must ride in a child safety seat unless the child is taller than four feet, nine inches.
Mistakes that cost people money
- Admitting to an adjuster that you were unbelted without context.
- Assuming the claim is worthless because you were not buckled.
- Letting the vehicle be destroyed before the restraint system is inspected.
- Ignoring how the crash type affects whether a belt would have helped.
Related questions
Will not wearing a seat belt reduce my settlement?
It can, if the insurer can show the missing belt made your injuries worse. The reduction is a percentage tied to the evidence, not an automatic cut.
What if my seat belt failed?
A belt that unlatched, tore, or failed to lock may support a product liability claim against the manufacturer. Preserve the vehicle and the belt.
Does the other driver’s fault matter if I was unbelted?
Yes. The other driver’s negligence in causing the crash is still the main question. Seat belt evidence goes to your share of responsibility for the injuries.
Can an insurance company deny my claim because I wasn’t wearing a seat belt in Texas?
Not on that basis alone. Under Nabors Well Services v. Romero (Tex. 2015), belt nonuse matters only if the defense shows it caused or contributed to your injuries, and then it reduces your recovery by a percentage. You are barred only if your total share of responsibility is more than 50 percent.
What is the fine for not wearing a seat belt in Texas?
Under Transportation Code section 545.413(d), an adult’s seat belt offense carries a fine of $25 to $50. A driver who lets a child younger than 17 ride without a required seat belt faces a fine of $100 to $200.
Does my car record whether I was wearing my seat belt?
Many cars do. Under 49 CFR Part 563, light vehicles built on or after September 1, 2012 that have an event data recorder must capture the driver’s belt status in qualifying crash events. The Texas crash report form also has a field for each person’s restraint use.
Does seat belt evidence matter if I was hit from the side?
It may matter less. The defense has to show the belt would have prevented or reduced your specific injuries, and injuries from door intrusion in a side impact can happen whether or not the occupant was belted. That is a question for medical and engineering evidence in each case.
Sources



