Quick answer

A letter of protection is a promise, usually from your lawyer, that a doctor or clinic will be paid from your settlement if they treat you now without insurance. It lets uninsured people get care after a crash, but the defense can challenge those bills, so they need to be reasonable.

Many people hurt in crashes have no health insurance, or a plan with a deductible they cannot meet. A letter of protection, often called an LOP, lets them see a doctor, get imaging, or have surgery now, with payment coming out of the recovery later.

In practice your lawyer sends the provider a letter agreeing to protect the bill from the settlement. You remain responsible for the charges, and if the case does not recover enough, the provider can still bill you, depending on the agreement. Read it before you sign.

LOP bills draw scrutiny. Providers working under letters of protection often charge full list prices. Civil Practice and Remedies Code section 41.0105 limits recovery of medical expenses to amounts actually paid or incurred, and in In re K & L Auto Crushers (2021) the Texas Supreme Court held that the rates a provider negotiates with insurers are discoverable when its charges to an uninsured plaintiff are disputed. A defense lawyer will use that to argue the bills are inflated.

That does not make an LOP a bad idea. It means the treatment should be medically necessary, the provider credible, and the charges defensible. A lawyer can also negotiate LOP balances down at settlement so more of the money reaches you.

Ask about other sources first, such as PIP, which Texas policies include unless you rejected it in writing under Insurance Code section 1952.152, and hospital charity programs. Owsley Law Firm helps clients find care and coordinates every bill and lien at settlement.

What to do, step by step

  1. Ask whether PIP, MedPay, or health insurance can pay first.
  2. Choose a provider whose treatment and pricing you can defend.
  3. Read the provider’s agreement before treatment.
  4. Keep copies of every bill and record.
  5. Let your lawyer negotiate the balance at settlement.
Gavel resting on a stack of law books

Defense lawyers may ask how a client was referred to a provider. Choosing reputable, independent doctors makes the treatment more persuasive.

A treating doctor’s explanation of why care was needed is often more important to a jury than the amount on the bill.

Letters of protection can be reduced at the end of a case. When coverage is limited, providers often accept less than the full balance so the case can close. Your lawyer negotiates those reductions as part of finishing the settlement.

If you later get health insurance, tell your lawyer and the provider. Switching how a bill is paid in the middle of treatment can raise questions, but coverage you have should generally be used.

Ask the provider for an itemized bill early and periodically, not just at the end. Seeing the charges as treatment goes on lets your lawyer raise concerns about pricing before the balance becomes a problem at settlement.

How does a letter of protection work in practice? The paperwork usually comes in a set. The lawyer’s letter to the provider promises payment of the bill from any recovery. The provider’s own financial agreement, signed by the patient, states what the patient owes and when. As treatment goes on, the provider sends records and itemized bills to the lawyer. At the end of the case, the lawyer pays the provider from the settlement funds, after any negotiated reduction, before the client’s share is released. Keeping copies of all three documents avoids surprises at closing.

Why do LOP bills get challenged? Because of how Texas measures medical damages. Civil Practice and Remedies Code section 41.0105 limits recovery to amounts actually paid or incurred, and in Haygood v. De Escabedo (2011) the Texas Supreme Court held that amounts a provider writes off are not recoverable and that only evidence of recoverable expenses is admissible. A patient treating under an LOP usually has had nothing written off, so the full charge is incurred. That is why the defense turns to In re K & L Auto Crushers to obtain the provider’s negotiated insurance rates and argue that the full charge is unreasonable.

How are LOP bills proved in court? Often by affidavit. Under Civil Practice and Remedies Code section 18.001, an affidavit from the provider or its records custodian supports a finding that the charges were reasonable and the services necessary unless the defense serves a counteraffidavit. The plaintiff serves the affidavit by the earlier of 90 days after the defendant answers or the expert deadline, and a counteraffidavit is due by the earlier of 120 days after the answer or the expert deadline. Once a counteraffidavit is served, the affidavit alone no longer settles reasonableness, and the treating provider’s credibility and testimony matter more.

What will the defense ask about the LOP? Expect it to be disclosed and examined. In a suit alleging physical injury, Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 194 requires the plaintiff to disclose medical records and bills reasonably related to the injuries, or an authorization for them, without waiting for a request. Defense discovery often goes further, asking how the patient found the provider, whether anyone referred them, and what the provider accepts from insurers for the same services. Truthful, consistent answers matter more than the fact that an LOP exists.

For example, suppose an uninsured warehouse worker in Pasadena has a herniated disc after a T-bone crash, has used the $2,500 in PIP on his policy, and needs an MRI and injections. A clinic agrees to treat him under a letter of protection. The charges are served with an 18.001 affidavit, and the defense serves a counteraffidavit disputing the price. At settlement, the lawyer asks the clinic to reduce its balance in light of the limited insurance and the challenge to the charges. Whether the clinic agrees, and how much reaches the worker, depends on the agreements and the facts. This illustration is hypothetical and is not a prediction of any result.

Which situations raise special issues? If you have health insurance but choose an LOP provider anyway, the defense may argue the higher charges were not reasonable, which is one reason to use coverage you have. If the case loses or recovers little, the provider’s financial agreement decides whether you still owe the balance. And a hospital that admitted you within 72 hours of the crash may hold a lien under Property Code section 55.002, which is separate from any LOP, has its own limits, and must be resolved at settlement alongside the LOP balances.

Mistakes that cost people money

  • Treating with a provider whose charges far exceed common rates.
  • Assuming you owe nothing if the case does not recover.
  • Getting care you would not otherwise need.
  • Hiding the letter of protection from the defense, which can learn of it in discovery.

Related questions

More on this topic.

Is a letter of protection the same as a lien?

Not exactly. A hospital lien comes from Property Code chapter 55; a letter of protection is a contract between you, your lawyer, and the provider.

Can I get surgery under a letter of protection?

Some surgeons and surgery centers accept them. The charges will be closely examined, so price and necessity matter.

Does using an LOP lower my settlement?

Not inherently, but inflated charges can be cut under section 41.0105. Reasonable charges hold up better.

Can a provider stop treating me under a letter of protection?

A provider can decide whether to accept an LOP and on what terms. Ask about that before treatment starts.

Can I get a letter of protection without a lawyer?

Letters of protection are usually issued by a lawyer, because the provider relies on the lawyer to pay from the settlement. Without one, a provider may ask for a different payment arrangement, so ask about its terms before treatment.

Will the jury know I treated under a letter of protection?

It can come up. The defense can learn of it in discovery and may use it to challenge the charges. What matters most is that the care was medically necessary and the charges reasonable.

Are letters of protection legal in Texas?

Yes. A letter of protection is a contract between the patient, the lawyer, and the provider. The charges are still limited by section 41.0105 to amounts paid or incurred and can be challenged as unreasonable.

Who signs a letter of protection?

Typically the lawyer signs the letter to the provider, and the patient signs the provider’s financial agreement or an authorization directing payment from the recovery. Read both documents before treatment starts.

Sources

Sources this page relies on

  1. Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 41.0105
  2. Tex. Ins. Code § 1952.152
  3. Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 18.001
  4. Texas Rules of Civil Procedure (Supreme Court of Texas)
  5. Tex. Prop. Code § 55.002
  6. Tex. Prop. Code ch. 55