Quick answer

You can usually pursue both the driver and the company. Texas holds an employer responsible for an employee’s negligent driving within the course and scope of the job, company vehicles typically carry far more insurance than the 30/60/25 minimum, and the company can also be liable for its own negligence in hiring, training, or entrusting the vehicle.

A crash with a company truck, van, or car is a different claim from a crash with a private driver. Under the doctrine Texas courts call respondeat superior, an employer answers for the negligence of an employee who was acting in the course and scope of employment. That matters because the company, not just the driver, becomes a defendant, and the company’s commercial policy becomes available.

The first fight is usually whether the driver was working. A plumber driving between service calls, a sales representative visiting clients, or a delivery driver on a route is plainly on the job. A driver who detoured for a personal errand, or who was commuting before the shift began, gives the company an argument that the employee was on a frolic of his own. Dispatch records, GPS and telematics data, delivery logs, fuel cards, and phone records usually answer the question, and they need to be preserved before the company’s retention cycle deletes them.

The company can also be liable for its own conduct, separate from the driver’s. Negligent hiring, retention, and supervision claims ask whether the company knew or should have known the driver was unsafe: a suspended license, prior crashes, failed drug tests, or a record of speeding tickets. Negligent entrustment asks whether the company handed a vehicle to someone it knew was unqualified. These claims open the company’s files, including the driver qualification records, training, and vehicle maintenance history.

Insurance is the practical reason this matters. Texas requires only $30,000 per person in liability coverage for private drivers under Transportation Code section 601.072. Business fleets usually carry commercial auto policies with higher limits and often an umbrella policy on top. If the vehicle is a commercial motor vehicle of 10,001 pounds or more used in interstate commerce, federal safety rules also apply, and federal minimum insurance levels apply when the company hauls goods for hire or carries hazardous materials (49 CFR 387.3).

Damages are the same as in any Texas injury case: medical expenses past and future, lost earnings and earning capacity, physical pain, mental anguish, physical impairment, and disfigurement. What changes is the size of the coverage behind the claim and the number of records available to prove it. Company cases also tend to involve adjusters who handle fleet claims every day, so a written claim backed by medical records and the company’s own data is far more effective than phone calls.

Owsley Law Firm handles company vehicle crashes across Texas, sends preservation demands for the company’s vehicle and driver records, and charges no fee unless it wins.

What to do, step by step

  1. Get the company name and vehicle number from the door or bumper.
  2. Photograph the vehicle, its markings, and the plate.
  3. Call the police and request the crash report.
  4. Have a lawyer send a preservation demand to the company.
  5. Use your own PIP coverage for early medical bills.
Close-up of a damaged car bumper on a road shoulder

Independent contractor status is the most common defense. Many delivery and service companies classify drivers as contractors, then argue the company is not responsible for their driving. Whether a worker is an employee for liability purposes turns on the company’s right to control the details of the work, not on the label in a contract. Uniform and vehicle requirements, route assignments, and scheduling control are all evidence.

Government vehicles follow different rules. If the vehicle belonged to a city, county, school district, or state agency, the Texas Tort Claims Act applies, with damages caps and a six-month written notice requirement, shorter under some city charters.

Timing matters more in company vehicle cases than in most. Fleet telematics systems and dashcams often overwrite data on a rolling cycle, and drivers’ phones and logs can be replaced. A written preservation demand sent early puts the company on notice that deleting the data could be treated as spoliation of evidence.

What happens step by step after a crash with a company vehicle? Note the company name, phone number, and unit number on the vehicle, and get the driver’s name and the name of the liability insurer, which Transportation Code section 550.023 requires every driver to give. Report the crash to your own insurer and open a PIP claim for early bills. Then a written claim and a preservation demand go to the company and its insurer. If a lawsuit is filed, Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 194 requires the defense to disclose any insurance or indemnity agreement that may cover the judgment, which is how the full layers of commercial coverage are confirmed.

Does the company have to prove the driver was off duty? At first, the facts work in your favor. In Robertson Tank Lines v. Van Cleave (1971), the Texas Supreme Court recognized that proof that a company owned the vehicle and employed the driver raises a presumption that the driver was acting in the course and scope of employment. The presumption disappears when the company offers positive evidence that the driver was on a personal mission, and then ownership and employment alone are not evidence of course and scope. That is why dispatch logs, GPS data, and work orders matter more than the driver’s own description.

What if the employee was driving a personal car or commuting? Under Painter v. Amerimex Drilling (2018), conduct is within the course and scope of employment when it is within the employee’s general authority, in furtherance of the employer’s business, and for the accomplishment of the object for which the employee was hired. Travel to and from work generally falls outside that, but not when the travel involves regular or specifically assigned duties for the employer. An employee running an assigned errand in a personal car can therefore still put the employer on the hook, and a driver in a marked company truck can be outside it during a purely personal detour.

How do company insurers and federal rules fit in? Fleet adjusters work for the company, and their early questions about speed, lanes, and your injuries are part of the defense investigation. Do not assume federal trucking minimums apply to every company vehicle. Under 49 CFR 387.3, the federal minimum insurance rules apply to for-hire carriers transporting property in interstate or foreign commerce and to carriers of hazardous materials, and not to vehicles under 10,001 pounds outside narrow hazardous material exceptions. A plumber’s or a retailer’s own fleet is usually governed by Texas minimums and whatever commercial policy the company chose to buy.

For example, suppose an HVAC company technician driving a company van between service calls in Spring runs a red light and strikes a driver’s car. The van is owned by the company and the technician is its employee, so the presumption from Robertson Tank Lines applies, and the dispatch records showing the next service call support it. The injured driver opens a PIP claim, a preservation demand goes to the company for the van’s telematics and the technician’s phone records, and the claim is made against the company’s commercial auto policy. How the claim resolves would depend on the medical records and the evidence of fault. This illustration is hypothetical and is not a prediction of any result.

Which situations complicate company vehicle claims? If the company stipulates that the driver was its employee acting in the course and scope of employment, Chapter 72 of the Civil Practice and Remedies Code limits how ordinary negligence claims directly against the company are tried in the first phase of a commercial vehicle case. If the vehicle was leased from a rental or leasing company, the Graves Amendment protects that owner unless it was negligent itself. And if the driver was texting, Transportation Code section 545.4251 makes it an offense to read, write, or send an electronic message on a portable device while driving unless the vehicle is stopped, and the company’s phone policies and the driver’s phone records become evidence.

Mistakes that cost people money

  • Giving a recorded statement to the company’s fleet insurer before talking to a lawyer.
  • Assuming only the driver’s personal policy applies.
  • Waiting so long that the company’s GPS, telematics, and dashcam data is overwritten.
  • Signing a property damage release that also releases injury claims.

Related questions

More on this topic.

What if the driver was on a lunch break?

It depends on the facts. A driver on a personal errand may be outside the course and scope of employment, while a driver making a work stop during the day may not. Dispatch and GPS records usually decide it.

Can I sue the company directly?

Often yes, both for the driver’s negligence through the employer’s responsibility and for the company’s own negligence in hiring, supervising, or entrusting the vehicle.

Does the company’s insurance pay my medical bills while the claim is pending?

Usually not until the claim resolves. Your own personal injury protection coverage can pay medical bills and lost income in the meantime, regardless of fault.

Is a company responsible if its employee was driving their own car?

It can be. Under Painter v. Amerimex Drilling (2018), the question is whether the driving was within the employee’s general authority, in furtherance of the employer’s business, and for the purpose the employee was hired. An assigned errand in a personal car can qualify, while an ordinary commute generally does not.

How do I find out what insurance a company vehicle has?

The driver must give the name of the liability insurer at the scene under Transportation Code section 550.023 and show proof of insurance on request under section 601.053. If a lawsuit is filed, Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 194 requires the company to disclose every insurance or indemnity agreement that may cover the judgment.

What if the company says the driver was off the clock?

Proof that the company owned the vehicle and employed the driver raises a presumption that the driver was working, under Robertson Tank Lines v. Van Cleave (1971). The company can rebut it with evidence of a personal mission, so dispatch logs, GPS data, timecards, and phone records usually decide the question.

Do federal insurance minimums apply to every company truck?

No. Under 49 CFR 387.3, the federal minimums apply to for-hire carriers hauling property in interstate commerce and to hazardous material carriers. A company’s own service or delivery fleet is usually covered by Texas minimums and whatever commercial policy the company carries.

Sources

Sources this page relies on

  1. Tex. Transp. Code § 601.072
  2. Texas Tort Claims Act, ch. 101
  3. Texas Rules of Civil Procedure (Supreme Court of Texas)
  4. Tex. Transp. Code § 550.023
  5. Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code ch. 72, subch. B
  6. Tex. Transp. Code § 545.4251
  7. Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code ch. 72