Quick answer

Civil Practice and Remedies Code section 72.001, the Texas guest statute, is still printed in the code, but Texas courts have held it unconstitutional and it is not applied. A family member riding for free can bring an ordinary negligence claim against the related driver, usually paid by that driver’s liability insurance. Owsley Law Firm reviews passenger claims and charges no fee unless we win.

The text of section 72.001 says a passenger riding free who is related to the driver or owner within the second degree can recover only for intentional or heedless and reckless conduct. Reading the code alone, it looks like current law. It is not.

In Whitworth v. Bynum (Tex. 1985), the Texas Supreme Court held the guest statute’s family-member limit unconstitutional under the equal rights guarantee of the Texas Constitution. The Legislature had carried the same words into section 72.001 when it recodified the civil statutes that year, and in Colvin v. Colvin (Tex. App. Tyler 2009) the court of appeals held that section 72.001 is unconstitutional too, noting that no published Texas case had applied it since Whitworth.

What did the Texas guest statute say?

Short answer

It limited a close relative riding free as a guest to claims for intentional conduct or heedless or reckless disregard by the related driver or owner.

The old statute covered passengers related to the owner or operator within the second degree of consanguinity or affinity, which includes a spouse, parents, children, siblings, grandparents, grandchildren, and in-laws within the same degrees. For those passengers it raised the bar from ordinary negligence to intentional or reckless conduct.

That is the text still printed as section 72.001. The reason it matters today is that insurers or online summaries sometimes quote it as if it still controls.

Pedestrian crosswalk at night with approaching headlights

Why is section 72.001 not enforced?

Short answer

Because Texas courts held it unconstitutional: Whitworth v. Bynum (Tex. 1985) struck down the guest statute, and Colvin v. Colvin (Tex. App. Tyler 2009) held that the recodified section 72.001 has the same defect.

In Whitworth, the Texas Supreme Court found that singling out relatives was not rationally related to the statute’s stated purpose of discouraging collusive lawsuits, and held the statute violated the equal rights provision of the Texas Constitution (article I, section 3).

In Colvin, a wife argued that the guest statute should have limited her husband’s claim after she crashed while driving. The court rejected the argument, explaining that the reenactment made no substantive change and carried the same defects found fatal in Whitworth, and held: section 72.001 is unconstitutional.

Can I sue a family member who was driving?

Short answer

Yes. A related passenger can bring an ordinary negligence claim against the driver, and the claim is normally paid by the driver’s liability insurance, not out of the family’s pocket.

The claim is made against the at-fault driver’s auto liability coverage, the same coverage that would pay a stranger. In Jilani v. Jilani (Tex. 1988), the Texas Supreme Court held that parental immunity does not bar a minor child’s suit against a parent for negligent driving.

Some policies try to exclude family members. In National County Mutual Fire Insurance Co. v. Johnson (Tex. 1993), the Texas Supreme Court held a family-member exclusion invalid as conflicting with the Texas motor vehicle insurance law, though the justices split on whether it is void entirely or only up to the statutory minimum limits. The policy language and limits deserve a close look.

Can a family passenger also recover from another driver?

Short answer

Yes. If another driver caused or contributed to the crash, the passenger can bring an ordinary negligence claim against that driver as well.

Under Chapter 33 of the Civil Practice and Remedies Code, responsibility can be divided between the drivers. A passenger who did nothing to cause the crash is usually not assigned a share of fault, so the claim may run against both drivers’ coverage.

Close-up of a damaged car bumper on a road shoulder

Does this apply to motorcycle passengers?

Short answer

Yes. A spouse or relative riding on a family member’s motorcycle can bring an ordinary negligence claim against the operator, and against any other at-fault driver.

Because motorcycle passengers often suffer serious injuries, the available liability, PIP, and uninsured or underinsured motorist coverage deserve close review.

How does PIP help a passenger?

Short answer

PIP on the vehicle’s policy covers passengers for medical and income losses without regard to fault, up to the limit.

PIP covers authorized operators and passengers, including guest occupants. Under Insurance Code section 1952.159, PIP paid by the driver’s insurer can be credited against a later liability claim by that passenger.

How it is proven after a crash

  • Evidence of the driver’s conduct
  • The other driver’s fault, if a second vehicle was involved
  • The driver’s liability policy, including any family-member exclusion
  • PIP and policy declarations
  • Medical records and bills

Mistakes that cost people money

  • Assuming a family passenger has no claim because of the old guest statute
  • Accepting an insurer’s reliance on section 72.001 without challenge
  • Overlooking a claim against the other driver
  • Not using PIP benefits

Frequently asked questions

Is the Texas guest statute still in effect?

No. The words remain in section 72.001, but Texas courts have held the statute unconstitutional, and no published Texas case has applied it since 1985.

Can I sue my spouse’s insurance after a crash?

Yes. A spouse riding as a passenger can bring an ordinary negligence claim, which is normally paid by the driver’s liability insurance.

Can my child make a claim against me if I caused the crash?

Yes. In Jilani v. Jilani (Tex. 1988), the Texas Supreme Court held that parental immunity does not bar a child’s claim against a parent for negligent driving, and the claim runs against the parent’s liability coverage.

Does it matter whether I paid for gas?

Not for the guest statute, since it is not enforced. Payment can still matter for other questions, such as whether a ride was a commercial trip.

Can a family passenger use PIP?

Yes. PIP covers passengers regardless of fault, up to the policy limit.

How long do I have to file?

Generally two years from the crash under section 16.003.

This page is general information about Texas law and is not legal or medical advice. Every case depends on its own facts. Contact the firm for a free review of yours.

Sources

Sources this page relies on

  1. Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 72.001
  2. Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code ch. 33
  3. Tex. Ins. Code § 1952.159
  4. Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 16.003